Jump to content
  • Palestinian Players Data Issue


    Archaic Concurrence
    • Files Uploaded: None Public Status: Open
     Share

    Description of issue

    Their are mutiple duplicates and data errors of several Palestinian Players, and I will listed them below.

    Duplicates:
    Hisham Salhi (2000267539) and Hesham Al-Salehi (23192259).
    Mohammad Khaled Ewaisat (2000305632) and Mohammed Uwesat (2000179032)
    Fahad Kanaan (2000034819) and Fahed Kanan (2000267547).

    Data Errors:

    Player Mohammed Ashour (23192305) is in fact 36 years old in the year of 2024.
    https://www.national-football-teams.com/player/30768/Mohammed_Ashour.html

    Player Mohammad Taha (2000164321):
    This player was between his age of 17 and 18 in FM22 DB, and is 19 yr old in FM 24, however, his birthday is in fact Nov. 12th 2003, which means he was at least 18-19 years old in 2021-2022, and should be at least 21 yr old in the year of 2024. The history shows that this Palestinian player plays for Al-Wasl for one season, during 2021-2022. However, no data shows that this player has ever joined any teams (from U16-U23) of Al Wasl. Since this player is no longer employed for 3 years, and you guys have messed up his data at the very beginning, you guys should consider removing him in FM 25. No data of this player that fits the gaming data could be found through the official website of Al-Wasl and all the other websites, including transfermarkt, official social media platforms of Al Wasl and etc.

    Those are the serious issues I have found so far. I would update other issues under this thread as long as I have found one.

    Steps to reproduce

    I try to find photos of players on the internet and it turns out the data of many players are mistaken.
     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    New foundings:
    Data Errors about players from Markaz Tulkarem (23091023):
    Mohammed Jamal (23192203):
    Wrong player transfer history: There are indeed different versions of it from the internet, but non of it fits the data in the game.
    The age and the date of birth is also incorrect. 

    References: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammed_Jamal_Jebreen
    https://www.pfa.ps/players/3596.html 

    Maan Jamal (2000027416) and Maen Obaid (5631482):
    They are dupilcates of each other with a messed up data set.
    Evidence:
    The game data demonstrate that both have been played for Merkaz Tulkarem from 08-11. In reality the palyer in facted played for this team initially from 06-11, which matches the in game date for both players. (Although 5631482's data shows that the player stayed in this club during 11-12, it is highly possible that it is incorrect.) The transfer history of 5631482 is also missing after 11-12.
    The data of 5631482 is completely messed up, the height, weight, and position renews randomly with every new save. One of the few things that remains is the appearances of his national team games which is six, it roughly fits the real-world data, which is 8(with 1 non fifa game). Meanwhile, there is no records shows 2000027416 had ever played for national team, which does not make sense.
    Most importantly: the full name of the player is Maan (Maen) Jamal Said Obaid, so it seems like both players' data in fact has a highly level similarity and both referred some facts in the reality. So please fix the data and remove the duplicate.
    https://www.national-football-teams.com/player/30779/Maen_Gamal_Obaid.html
    https://www.pfa.ps/players/3596.html

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...