mattock or bale

[FM finest]

I want to sign either one of them but cant decide as i like mattock cause hes english but bale is good.

so can you tell me who is the best british lefy back in the game thanks:)

[Hog]

Bale is better and has more potential but Mattock is cheaper.

[Haynes28]

However Mattock can turn out to be better than Bale if he achieves his full potential and Bale doesn't achieve his.

[arsenal_2111]

Bale is much more attacking, whereas Mattock is good at both sides of the game.

Also, Bale is better from the start and generally has more potential. However he will be very expensive, around £16million.

Mattock is fairly average at the start of the game, and he can either turn out very good or average. The plus side, however, is that his price is around £2-3million, making him better value.

So, for an almost guarenteed good player, Bale. But considering the price difference, Mattock would be my preference.

[marshalllfc]

Bale...... when you look at mattock on editor his currant rating is something like 100 and his potential rating is -7 (93) bale alot better

[arsenal_2111]

Bale...... when you look at mattock on editor his currant rating is something like xxx and his potential rating is xx bale alot better

Firstly, those figures are wrong by quite a long way. But secondly, mentioning PA or CA outside of spoiler tags (

[ /spoiler]) is against the rules - best to edit them out although, like I said, they are wrong by a lot.

[Lisandro Lopez]

You should use the Buy/Sell thread. Plus your club thread, i.e Man Utd.

Fullback thread

For what it's worth, for me; Bale will be the better, but Mattock turns out either good or very good. You can’t go wrong with either.