Who is the better Assistant Manager?

[Elitee]

The 2nd picture are the stats of my current AM, and the 1st picture is one I just found. He is normally a coach or Goalkeeper coach preferred but enough wages got him to agree to be my AM, he is also 30 years old.

I use my AM for all the press talk, team selection sometimes and a few other things. Not sure which is better and if him not being selected for an AM position will have an effect on anything. 

[Lem]

There's a lot to consider, some of which isn't in those screenshots.
Do you use your AM for coaching? The 2nd one is obviously quite a good outfield coach, particularly for tactics. The first doesn't look much for coaching but I'd think is a better AM. Entirely depends how often you assign certain things to them - high motivating and man management are important, and judging players. His tactical knowledge is slightly worse though, which if you use him to pick formations/teams and advise on strategy could be an issue, but it's not exactly low.
On stats I favour the top one, but is his personality suitable? Does determined match your squad? What about his media handling style? Does he favour the same formations and tactics/style as you?
 

[FrazT]

1. has  the better mental attributes for AM and as long as you dont involve him in any tactical decisions or in game feedback, will be the better AM.

2. is the better coach, if that is what you want from your AM

[Hoodmatty]

I always go for a coach as an assistant manager usually with decent tactical attributes so do Number 2 tasks. I think having an assistant manager with the key AM attributes is a bit of a waste if your at a club with limited resources, having said that when i'm in charge of a big club i rule with my heart and bring back a club legend who usually has terrible attributes.