Jump to content

FM2009 Rate My Team Thread


arsenal_2111

Recommended Posts

Unlike last year, this thread is for getting ratings on your team rather than advice. If you were posting regularly last year, you would realise that if you posted for advice in here people would tell you how to improve your team, normally in quite detailed responces. But this year we are going back to FM07 style - this thread is for getting a rating out of 10 for your team.

To get detailed responces on your team, post in the Improve My Team thread.

Post a screenshot of your team and people will give it a rating from 1-10, and will probably give you a short peice of advice about your team. A rating, followed by recommending positions to improve in.

If someone would be kind enough to post up a screenshot of their team I will post an ideal reply.

Thanks all:)

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Replies 382
  • Created
  • Last Reply

..............almunia

sagna......toure....fazio.....clichy

theo.........cesc....veloso....nasri

................rvp......ade

subs

.........................fabianski

eboue............djourou.......song.......silvestre

balotelli............denilson....diaby......vela

......................bendtner....saivet

Link to post
Share on other sites

.........................................Hart

................zarbaleta.....Naldo.......Richards....Tawio

...........................G.Fernandes.....j.martinez

.........SWP.........................Elano..........................Robinho

........................................lavezzi

Link to post
Share on other sites

xDieArdUk

Cech - 9

Rafinha - 7

Terry - 9

Pepe - 9

Cole - 8

Essein - 9

Lampard - 10

Robben - 9

Deco - 9

Agbonlahor - 8

Tevez - 8

Positions To Improve On:

* It's more of a case of replacing your ageing stars slowly.

* ST is another possible area to improve on.

* Robben, class but injury prone so I'd advice you having a class replacement for the numerous times he's injured.

* Rafinha, isn't the best, you could do better but he’s not that bad either.

Link to post
Share on other sites

thebigman1985

Almunia - 7

Sagna - 8

Toure - 8

Fazio - 9

Clichy - 8

Theo - 8

Cesc - 10

Veloso - 9

Nasri - 9

RVP - 9

Adebayor - 8

Subs:

Fabianski - 7

Eboue - 6

Djourou - 6

Song - 6

Silvestre - 4

Balotelli - 9

Denilson - 9

Diaby - 7

Vela - 9

Bendtner - 8

Saivet -8

Positions To Improve On:

* GK, you should look to bring in a much better goalkeeper.

* Subs, I think you can improve on your second choice options. You should look to offload some of the poorer players such as Silvestre for example.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Carlos the Blue

Howard - 6

Neville - 5

Yobo - 7

Jagielka - 7

Lescott - 7

Arteta - 8

Moutinho - 8

Felliani - 9

Arda - 8

Cahill - 9

Doyle - 8

Positions To Improve On:

* GK, you can get better goalkeepers then Howard.

* Neville, ageing and not that great look for a replacement especially long term wise.

* Lescott is wasted at LB for me, so look to get in a LB of pedigree.

* ST, another striker perhaps.

Link to post
Share on other sites

luke.smith

Hart - 7

Zarbaleta - 7

Naldo - 7

Richards - 9

Tawio - 8

G.Fernandes - 6.5

Martinez - 8

SWP - 8

Elano - 8

Robinho - 8.5

Lavezzi - 7

Positions To Improve On:

* There are better options out there than Naldo, he's good but I've seen a few who are much better.

* Gelson, he's nothing that special for me. You could improve here.

* ST, Lavezzi is pretty good but who else is back up ST? You might wish to improve your other options here.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Udinese

GK: Handanovic Belardi

DR: Motta, Ferronetti, Nef

DC: Felipe, Zapata, Coda, Domizzi, Sala

DL: Lukovic, Pasquale, Moreno

MC: D'Agostino, Inler, Tissone, Obodo, Appiah

FR-FL: Di Natale, Sanchez, Pepe

ST: Quagliarella, Floro Flores, Ronaldo (fat brazilian).

Sorry, 1st season no kitty :-P just got appiah and ronaldo on a free and loaned some youngsters

Link to post
Share on other sites

Im aston Villa in my 2nd season first season won FA Cup came 9th in prem

GK - Leo Franco/ Oscar Ustaria

DR - Belletti / luke young

DC- David Luiz & Curtis Davies / Carlos Cuellar, martin laursen

DL - Nicky Shorey

ML - Simon Vukcevic

MC- Gareth Barry & Miguel Veloso / reo-coker

ST - Owen & Oscar Cardozo / John carew

Link to post
Share on other sites

Team: Sporting CP

GKs: Ustari, Rui Patricio, Batista

CBs: Carriço, Caneira, Polga, Nordtveit

DLs: Ronny, Grimi

DRs: Pedro Silva, Abel

MCs: Moutinho, Veloso, Rochemback, Izmailov, Adrien

AMLs: Vukcevic, Saivet

AMRs: Pereirinha, Ninis

STs: Liedson, Postiga, Djalo, Derlei, Tiui

Link to post
Share on other sites

Only just started but here

ManCity.jpg?t=1227299740

Obviously going to improve the squad a bit more as I have only brought the 3 players, Lucho (who is a FM God by the way), Arshavin and Srna, looking for another central defender (hopefully Mexes) and a striker (hopefully Quagliarella)

Link to post
Share on other sites

adamj11

Schmeichal - 6.5

Srna - 9

Dunne - 6

Ben-Haim - 6

Garrido - 6.5

Lucho - 8.5

Elano - 7

SWP - 8

Petrov - 8

Arshavin - 7.5

Robinho - 8

Positions To Improve On:

* GK - Get a better goalkeeper than either of those two.

* CB - Replace one of your current CB with Richards, he's going to be much better than both Dunne/Ben-Haim put together! Use him you could/should still buy another CB.

* Garrido - Either get a better LB or put Srna on the left and Zabaleta on the right.

* ST - You should look to bring in a class striker.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Mwtralha

GKs

Ustari - 7.5

Rui Patricio - N/A

Batista - N/A

Defence

Carriço - ?

Caneira - ?

Polga - 6

Nordtveit - 7.5

Ronny - ?

Grimi - ?

Pedro Silva -?

Abel - ?

Midfield

Moutinho - 8

Veloso - 9

Rochemback - 6

Izmailov - ?

Adrien - 7

Vukcevic - 8.5

Saivet - 8

Pereirinha - ?

Ninis - 7.5

Strikers

Liedson - 7

Postiga - 6

Djalo - ?

Derlei - ?

Tiui - ?

Positions To Improve On

I can only rate the players I know about so the "?" are because I don't know enough about them so would be difficult to say. I'd say what you should look to do is start selling your older players and look to bring in young talented calibre of players who can develop and progress.

Link to post
Share on other sites

My Manchester United side first season so far.............

Van der sar

Evra

Vidic

Ferdinand

G.Neville

C.Ronaldo

Anderson

Carrick

Nani

Rooney

Balotelli

Subs:

Kuszczak

Brown

Evans

Hargreaves

Scholes

Angel Di Maria

Iam looking to improve in the defensive midfield department,so far ive played 16 won 11 and drew 5 in the league.

Any suggestions? i got these players coming next season:

Mascio

losu llorente

davide santon

francisco rosales

jose baxter

Link to post
Share on other sites

Cleggy-Liverpool FC

Gomes - 7.5

Glen Johnson - 7

David Luiz - 8.5

Corluka - 7.5

Bale - 8

Bentley - 7

Veloso - 9

Van Der Vaart - 9

Modric - 8.5

Keirrison - 7.5

Afonso Alves - 7

Pazzini - 7.5

Subs:

Ustari - 7

King - 7

Giovani - 8

Wilshere - 8

Camacho - 8

Victor Moses - 7.5

Alan Dzagoev - 8

Positions To Improve On

* RB

* MR/AMR - Bentley's spot.

* ST - Afonso is nothing special.

Link to post
Share on other sites

burnie24

Van der sar - 7

Evra - 8.5

Vidic - 9

Ferdinand - 9

G.Neville - 6

C.Ronaldo - 9

Anderson - 8.5

Carrick - 7.5

Nani - 7

Rooney 7.5

Balotelli - 8.5

Subs:

Kuszczak - 6

Brown - 7

Evans - 7

Hargreaves - 7

Scholes - 7

Angel Di Maria - 8

Positions To Improve On

Can't tell you what players to get, not in this thread anyway. What I would say is you should look to improve imo at:

* GK

* RB

* DM

* ST, maybe.

Link to post
Share on other sites

My Celtic Team 2nd season (sorry dont know how to do screenshots)

..................Boruc

Hinkel..Simunek..McManus..Guilherme

McGeady..Cattermole..Brown..Maloney

... Vennegoor of Hesselink...Sturridge

SUBS

Brown

O'Dea

Robson

Nakamura

Wijnaldum

S.Fletcher

C.Evans

Link to post
Share on other sites

My Arsenal Team 2009

GK: Sergio Asenjo

LB: Arthur Boka

RB: Bakery Sagna

CB: Kolo Toure

CB: Federico Fazio

LM: Samir Nasri

RM: Theo Walcott

CM: Cesc Fabregas

CM: Yaya Toure

ST: Emmanuel Adebayor

ST: Guiseppe Rossi

Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice team but Abidal, Puyol and Yaya need replacement.

I know but all three are playing great for me. I'm in middle of January 2009 and they've played in all the league games so far with good ratings - Abidal=7.38, Puyol=7.36 and Yaya=7.44 plus 5 goals from long shots.

Next season I will have Henrique coming back from loan and I want to buy Clichy and Sunny. For the offense I want only Aguero!

What do ya think about these future additions and this future starting line up:

GK Valdes

DR Alves

DL Clichy

DC Pique

DC Fazio

MC Veloso

MCr Xavi

MCl Iniesta

AMC Messi

FC Aguero

FC Eto'o

My second season Dream Team

Link to post
Share on other sites

My team as Manchester United end of 2nd season

Van der Sar/Frillio (the young gun from Samp)

Hargreaves Rio/Fazio Vidic Evra/Evans

Anderson/Carrick Veloso/Camacho

Ronaldo/Aguero Giovincio/Nani/Wilshire

Rooney/Balotelli Tevez/Berbatov

i also have 4 excellent regens that i use now and again.

Link to post
Share on other sites

My team as Manchester United end of 2nd season

Van der Sar/Frillio (the young gun from Samp)

Hargreaves Rio/Fazio Vidic Evra/Evans

Anderson/Carrick Veloso/Camacho

Ronaldo/Aguero Giovincio/Nani/Wilshire

Rooney/Balotelli Tevez/Berbatov

i also have 4 excellent regens that i use now and again.

VDS - He is ace but probs replace him with Frillo at the start of next season. 8

Hargreaves - strong here. 9

Rio - Solid and Fazio is pure class. 10

Vidic - absolute rock. 9

Evra/Evans - not the strongest here, should improve. 6

Anderson - he is stunning. 10

Veloso - Brilliant, and a good prospect coming through. 9

Ronaldo/Aguero - can't get any better here. 10

AML - 3 amazing prospects, you should swap them around. 8

Rooney/Balotelli - fantastic, can't get any better. 10

Tevez/Berba - quite good here too. 8

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

For mines, i've made too signings, Capdevila (in for Rat) and Enyema (will swap around with Hart)

Cheers

Link to post
Share on other sites

Dave-

Casillas - 10

Ramos - 9

Zapata - 8.5

Pepe - 8

Marcelo - 6 as left back

Guardado - 7.5

Gago - 7.5

Sneijeder - 8

Robben -8

RVN - 7

Higauin - 7.5

But thats just my opinion.

Pretty much agree but Guardado - 7.5? Rubbish. Also Marcelo - 6?? (is accomplished at left back) he has a so not sure what you're basing those scores on lol.

Link to post
Share on other sites

dave byrd

Don't post PA/CA outside of the two PA/CA thread, if you wish to do so use the spoiler tags. Also with regards to his rating, Marcelo is very poor as a left back due to his poor defensive ability, great attacking wise but weak at defending. Ratings are used on what the player is like at the moment not what he could be like in a few years time. Keep that in mind.

Link to post
Share on other sites

VDS - He is ace but probs replace him with Frillo at the start of next season. 8

Hargreaves - strong here. 9

Rio - Solid and Fazio is pure class. 10

Vidic - absolute rock. 9

Evra/Evans - not the strongest here, should improve. 6

Anderson - he is stunning. 10

Veloso - Brilliant, and a good prospect coming through. 9

Ronaldo/Aguero - can't get any better here. 10

AML - 3 amazing prospects, you should swap them around. 8

Rooney/Balotelli - fantastic, can't get any better. 10

Tevez/Berba - quite good here too. 8

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

For mines, i've made too signings, Capdevila (in for Rat) and Enyema (will swap around with Hart)

Cheers

cheers, sounds good. i have just sold Evra for 24 million to Madrid, and one of the 16 year old regens will fill my left back spot until i can find a decent one

Link to post
Share on other sites

Your welcome Libertine ;)

Anybody got comments to make on mine? Ill repost the newest team;

Volkan

Diarra Richards Kompany Capdevila

Veloso

Wright-Phillips Vekcevic

Fernandez Robinho

Nihat

Please give me some comments, cheers.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Volkan - 7.5 ( not played with him much though)

Diarra - 7 (better as a DM)

Richards - 9

Kompany - 7.5

Capdevila - 7.5

Veloso - 9

Wright-Phillips - 8

Vekcevic - 8.5

Fernandez - 9

Robinho - 8 ( not his strongest position)

Nihat - 8.5

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thandui

Gomes - 7.5

Belleti – 6

Bale – 8

King – 7

Corluka - 7.5

Santon - 7.5

Veloso – 9

Modric – 8

Vukcevic – 8.5

Lewandowski – 7

Pavlyuchenko – 7

Zuculini – 7

Haruna – 7

Dos Santos – 7.5

David Luiz – 8.5

Keirrison – 8

Campell – 7

Bentley – 7

Palermo – 7.5

Hutton – 7

Nakamura - 7

Players that I missed out rating is because I don't know what there like on FM09.

Positions To Improve:

* Replace Belleti with Santon at RB, unless that’s just because of injuries and is short term.

* MR, I think you can get better players than any MR option you have at the moment.

Link to post
Share on other sites

This is my Aston Villa squad at the start of the second season. What do you think?

GK – Asenjo / Guzan

DR – Anyukov / Torres

DL – Marcelo / Bouma

DC – Radoi / Laursen

DC – Davies / Cacares

MC – Reo-Coker / Camacho

MC – Veloso / Ramires

AMR – Milner / Acosta

AML – Young / Di Maria

ST – Huntelaar / Agbonlahor

ST – Owen / Rossi

The players listed first are the first choice team, followed by the back-up at each position. I think it's pretty good :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Spike

GK: Asenjo is a great 'keeper to buy on fm09 -8

DR: Anyukov is another greatly improved player -8

DL: Marcelo is great getting forward but is shocking defensively, bouma isn't really good enough -7

DC: Radoi, Davies and Cacares are all very good here so rotate them how you please, laursen is also a solid back up -8.5

MC: Player Veloso here as much as possilbe as he is an absolute beast, then rotate your other 3 depending on your style of play -8

AMR: Milner is a great technical player but lacks the pace for a great winger, Acosta is the opposite -7.5

AML: Young is definitely now one of the best wingers in the game, Di Maria is also brilliant -8.5 (Btw, how about playing Young on the right?)

ST: Amazing choice here, you've got every type of striker there is. Owen is an amazing finisher along with Rossi. Huntelaar is also a great target man and Agbonlahor's pace is unbeatable. This is probably your strongest area of the pitch :thup: 9

Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's my Stoke City side as of April 2010

GK: Thomas Sorensen

DR: Giourkas Seitaridis

DL: Vasco Regini

DC: Andriy Rusol

DC: Abdoulaye Faye

MR: Anouar Diba

ML: Juan Angel Albin

MC: Alberto (to be replaced by van der vaart this summer)

MC: Marco Zambelli

ST: Jozy Altidore

ST: Robert Lewandowski

Subs

S1: Lukasz Zaluska

S2: Danny Higginbotham

S3: Fredrik Ljungberg

S4: Luis Boa Morte

S5: Angelo Antonazzo

S6: Macauley Chrisantus

S7: Sadick Adams

Link to post
Share on other sites

Spike

GK: Asenjo is a great 'keeper to buy on fm09 -8

DR: Anyukov is another greatly improved player -8

DL: Marcelo is great getting forward but is shocking defensively, bouma isn't really good enough -7

DC: Radoi, Davies and Cacares are all very good here so rotate them how you please, laursen is also a solid back up -8.5

MC: Player Veloso here as much as possilbe as he is an absolute beast, then rotate your other 3 depending on your style of play -8

AMR: Milner is a great technical player but lacks the pace for a great winger, Acosta is the opposite -7.5

AML: Young is definitely now one of the best wingers in the game, Di Maria is also brilliant -8.5 (Btw, how about playing Young on the right?)

ST: Amazing choice here, you've got every type of striker there is. Owen is an amazing finisher along with Rossi. Huntelaar is also a great target man and Agbonlahor's pace is unbeatable. This is probably your strongest area of the pitch :thup: 9

Thanks for the feedback Piddy.

I am trying to convert Marcelo into a proper left back. I have got his tackling up to 12, and it should increase to 13 very soon.

I agree that Veloso is a beast, which is why I have just turned down a £40m bid Man City. It’s a great offer (all £40m up front) but I wouldn’t be able to replace him.

As for my attacking midfielders, this is what my assistant manager has recommended. As he is World Class I have taken his advice, but can always interchange them if it doesn’t work out right.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok, my Chelsea team:

GK: Mandanda

DR: Srna

DL: A.Cole

CB: Terry

CB: Zapata

MC:Essien

MC: Veloso

AMR: Giovinco (retrained)

AML: Guardado

AMC: Robinho

FC: Balotelli!

Other Players:

Cech

Demichellis

Mancienne

Radoi

Kuzmanovic

Arshavin

Fausto Rossi

Keirisson

Oscar Cardozo

Jack Wilshere

Sergio Asenjo!

What do you boys think?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Man City First Season

First Eleven

GK Mandanda

DR Srna

DL Kolarov

DC Micah Richards

DC Dunne

MC Palombo

MC Veloso

AMR SWP

AML Petrov

ST Robinho

ST Pogrebnyak

7 Subs:

GK Joe Hart

DC Onuoha

DC Kompany

MC Camacho

AMR Balotelli

AML Di Maria

ST Caicedo

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...