Jump to content

Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 38.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

1 hour ago, Swagata1998 said:

Tactic for underdog teams like west ham? please suggest I seem to get sacked everytime. Cant find a stable tactic.

4420 seems to work for west ham(holidays, no transfers). 

 

image.thumb.png.da048abd693f31da0f405f7cb8110151.png

 

 

 

442 beowulf is quite good as well (holidays too)

 

image.thumb.png.ccdb8c3ac143f2f3d517810bee40e21f.png

 

ME23.0WHEELSOFFiiREKnap4420DMP101EC.fmf ME23.0BEOWULFKnap442WAFP10OEC.fmf

Edited by Сука Блять
Link to post
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Сука Блять said:

4420 seems to work for west ham(holidays, no transfers). 

 

image.thumb.png.da048abd693f31da0f405f7cb8110151.png

 

 

 

442 beowulf is quite good as well (holidays too)

 

image.thumb.png.ccdb8c3ac143f2f3d517810bee40e21f.png

 

ME23.0WHEELSOFFiiREKnap4420DMP101EC.fmf 45.04 kB · 7 downloads ME23.0BEOWULFKnap442WAFP10OEC.fmf 44.93 kB · 7 downloads

Even using knap tactic i just cant win the away matches in these years beta version. For 5 seasons  I have been stuck in mid table team.Can't improve on the previous performances. Specially the away matches are the main problems.

Link to post
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, Swagata1998 said:

Even using knap tactic i just cant win the away matches in these years beta version. For 5 seasons  I have been stuck in mid table team.Can't improve on the previous performances. Specially the away matches are the main problems.

Have you tried tweaking mentality (or basically anything) on away games? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

With their stupidly high transfer budget and abundance of players you can sell on for good profit, I have recently started a save as Brighton.

I can upload a screenshot of my squad later when I get home from work but is there a tactic you guys would recommend? I really like the look of HOLY GHOST FIRE 41131 POSSESSION P103 EC CC and was wondering if it could work? How long do you guys give tactics to bed in? I have tried other HGF Knap tactics already this season but I am worried I have not given them enough time to work or I have chosen the right one(s).

Link to post
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, davecrossley33 said:

With their stupidly high transfer budget and abundance of players you can sell on for good profit, I have recently started a save as Brighton.

I can upload a screenshot of my squad later when I get home from work but is there a tactic you guys would recommend? I really like the look of HOLY GHOST FIRE 41131 POSSESSION P103 EC CC and was wondering if it could work? How long do you guys give tactics to bed in? I have tried other HGF Knap tactics already this season but I am worried I have not given them enough time to work or I have chosen the right one(s).

If I'm looking for a tactic to win right away, I'll just pick the highest points/goal differential. If I'm picking a tactic for a long-term save, I'll pick anything I want (even down to aesthetics, or if I prefer one role to another) and just gradually get guys to fill those roles. Your team might start out with no suitable SS players, but if you sign one in your first transfer window, a whole bunch of 4231s open up for you!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, you're definitely right.

Like with a lot of other FM players, I am expecting instant results. I feel getting a tactic in and letting the players get used to it will definitely get the best results. What I should do is adapt my mentality when playing against bigger teams and see how I get on from there.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guys, in pre season you need at least 8 friendly games, i'm going for at least 10

All 3 tactic slots are used

Let the players learn the tactic, by october my teams are playing like well oiled machines

If you play with a top team good results will come quicker, mid table or lower teams will need more time and better players

Link to post
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, davecrossley33 said:

With their stupidly high transfer budget and abundance of players you can sell on for good profit, I have recently started a save as Brighton.

I can upload a screenshot of my squad later when I get home from work but is there a tactic you guys would recommend? I really like the look of HOLY GHOST FIRE 41131 POSSESSION P103 EC CC and was wondering if it could work? How long do you guys give tactics to bed in? I have tried other HGF Knap tactics already this season but I am worried I have not given them enough time to work or I have chosen the right one(s).

I tried Brighton yesterday for around half a season with knap's HOLY GHOST FIRE 451 VOL2 P105 ALL CUPS both manually and on holidays and it gave me quite good results(7th on holidays, 3rd manually both no transfers but while manually tweaked tactic a bit depending on game) but honestly from what I personally tried so far the only knap's tactic that was very random result-wise is the first possession one., so just pick the one you like and it should work if you give it the time for your players to learn it. 

Edited by Сука Блять
Link to post
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, knap said:

ME 23.0 BETA

HOLY GHOST FIRE 4231 POSSESSION P15 EC CC

ME23.0HOLYGHOSTFIREKnap41231POSSP105EC.fmf 46.71 kB · 16 downloads

1220102458_Screenshot(2108).thumb.png.f2bd4a8214d4839e0ba256c38d5a3645.png2143038675_Screenshot(2106).thumb.png.fda6a211c040fab5fdbffb38b8e28bdd.png390052477_Screenshot(2107).thumb.png.3b2562be4786088f4e05792919d201bb.png

what's the advantage you get from playing the RB as IWB on attack as opposed to a WB on support like the LB?

Is it connected to the right sided CM being played as a CM on support and the left sided CM being the BBM on support?

In short, would it be detrimental to also make the RB a WB on support?

Link to post
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, knap said:

@davecrossley33

It is based on a 451 PEP Recreation tactic which I morph into other tactics.

Any role or duty change how the tactic plays out.

in short, would you advise I do not change it then? If so, I may need to find someone that isn't Tariq Lamptey to play there haha

Edited by davecrossley33
Link to post
Share on other sites

HOLY GHOST FIRE 4231 POSSESSION P15 EC CC

West ham, Atalanta and Villareal (3 teams I usually use for holiday testing) - so 3 non-top teams - full season on holidays

Overall seems to have mixed results for non-top teams, but when playing manually and buying right players/choosing better teams seems to be possible to make it be good enough, but definitely not plug-and-play for all teams.

Villareal fired after 27 games, possession was okay

image.png.a5a531ce5a15f0a29fd745359068c55d.pngimage.thumb.png.e7c60a922bda1f6250c3aef00a4a6810.png

 

Westham - not great not terrible - both in terms of position and possession. Won conference league, English cup was mediocre.

The biggest positive is that main striker Scamacca scored 42 goals in all competitions.

 

image.thumb.png.0f7549a714053e9c1c39c3413012cc1a.png

image.png.c34208467ab15f14f3b69e42674f4ece.png

 

Atalanta worked better, both position and possession were quite good.

 

image.png.fe8de8c9dd17a0559b3e684ab95eb06c.pngimage.thumb.png.4c0fe8ed0ce9b6acde8778b5b7c6f3df.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...