Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List

[knap]

@monsalai

Generally as wingers, but worth switching sometimes just to add variation.

[knap]

Lower League test with Havant

[kelevra]

32 minutes ago, knap said:

Lower League test with Havant

I've just started a long term save with Dulwich Hamlet gonna use this tactic and see if it can get me through the leagues, I've used beowulf 424 mostly so want to try something different.

[knap]

ME 23.2

WHEELS OF FIRE BAL 41212 W AF P107 FA

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnapBAL41212WAFP107FA.fmf

[pan1majonez]

I don't under stand this FM23. I played Almeria, used Your best tactic from CA 120 and in the middle of season i had place 16/20. In the second half of the season i used Your best CA 140 and i finished season 7/20 and i promoted to the league conference... 

[Emrekellegoz]

[Smiza]

@knap do you plan on releasing more time tactics (without pis)?

[smokecat]

25 dakika önce, Emrekellegoz said:

Hangi Taktik?

 

[Emrekellegoz]

36 dakika önce, smokecat said:

Hangi Taktik?

 

 

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnapBAL41212WDAFP106FA.fmf

[knap]

@pan1majonez

It is only a rough guide and rng is a big factor. Also a change in tactic may have given the squad a boost. 

[knap]

ME 23.2

WHEELS OF FIRE BAL 4123  AF P101 FA

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnapBAL4123AFP101FA.fmf

[knap]

@Smiza

Not many PIs on current tactics, could try removing them.

[kandersson]

On 10/04/2023 at 13:09, knap said:

ME 23.2

ARGUS PEP 3241 P102

ME23.2ARGUSKnapPEP3241MCP102.fmf 47.21 kB · 74 downloads

 

 

Looks great and also gets rid of full backs which become really hard to find after a few seasons 

[knap]

@kandersson

I as surprised how well it played, although I could not replicate the Grealish role from the last game.

[knap]

ME 232

WHEELS OF FIRE  BAL 4123 W AF P99 EC FA

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnapBAL4123WAFP99ECFA.fmf

 

[knap]

ME 23.2

WHEELS OF FIRE BAL 41221 OXFORD P103 CC

 

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnapBAL41221OXFORDP103EC.fmf

 

[wisconsin]

Do you use the same set piece routines with all your tactics? Do you get many goals from them?

[pan1majonez]

13 hours ago, knap said:

@pan1majonez

Jest to tylko przybliżony przewodnik, a rng jest dużym czynnikiem. Również zmiana taktyki mogła dać drużynie impuls. 

Best CA120 and my team had first place in the losing goals. I am playing from FM 2005 and i had first time this situation

[I.M.F.C]

Hi @knap

what is the best realistic tactic for this ME ?

I'm using rocksteady 42121 Narrow with success, but do you see another one ?

 

[knap]

@pan1majonez

I am not sure about any of the test leagues.

Mr Hough has his own test and top is this version of BEOWULF, give it a try and see if it works for you

ME23.2BEOWULFKnapBALSP424IFVOLP104ALLCPSMRHTweak.fmf

 

[knap]

@I.M.F.C

Not sure what you mean by realistic.

Formations possibly 3241 as City were using that the other night.  4231 Double pivots. 442 with or without double pivots. 451 or 433 used by many Clubs. 343 IF and 352 would be Spurs.

 

[knap]

@wisconsin

Not really as depends on tactic and formation, also can aim at a striker like Haaland.

If attacking corners near post far post or a mix. RNG applies but with a top side normally top in goals from corners, but also have more corners than the AI.

[Suffpunch89]

Seems a bit of a silly post now but killing some time of work with fm21 😂💵

anyone care to share with me the most enjoyable tactic people remember using ? 

[Ianthefatboy]

34 minutes ago, Suffpunch89 said:

Seems a bit of a silly post now but killing some time of work with fm21 😂💵

anyone care to share with me the most enjoyable tactic people remember using ? 

for me, it's always Knap's Mad As A Hatter 4132. been enjoying that tactics since FM19 and still using it this FM. The spread of players that you get to use is just fun. 1 CM, 2 Wingers, 1 CAM, 2 strikers. you get the opportunity to fill your squad with plethora of players from plethora of positions, makes transfer window and promoting young players a lot more exciting in my opinion.

[Suffpunch89]

1 hour ago, Ianthefatboy said:

for me, it's always Knap's Mad As A Hatter 4132. been enjoying that tactics since FM19 and still using it this FM. The spread of players that you get to use is just fun. 1 CM, 2 Wingers, 1 CAM, 2 strikers. you get the opportunity to fill your squad with plethora of players from plethora of positions, makes transfer window and promoting young players a lot more exciting in my opinion.

Thanks Ian ! I’m on it 💥 

[Ianthefatboy]

18 minutes ago, Suffpunch89 said:

Thanks Ian ! I’m on it 💥 

Have fun with it brother!

[I.M.F.C]

Il y a 5 heures, knap a dit :

@I.M.F.C

Not sure what you mean by realistic.

Formations possibly 3241 as City were using that the other night.  4231 Double pivots. 442 with or without double pivots. 451 or 433 used by many Clubs. 343 IF and 352 would be Spurs.

 

I mean realistic tactic like 433, 442, 4231, 352...
The shape of best tactics on FM Arena for example are so unreal...
I'm looking for a realistic one.

[knap]

 

@I.M.F.C

As mentioned I am not sure test leagues work that well. I have a couple of 4123s, but that formation is not the best.

Plenty of realistic formations on docs

This is currently on test but just post the formation you want and I will find/make a tactic

[I.M.F.C]

Il y a 1 heure, knap a dit :

 

@I.M.F.C

As mentioned I am not sure test leagues work that well. I have a couple of 4123s, but that formation is not the best.

Plenty of realistic formations on docs

This is currently on test but just post the formation you want and I will find/make a tactic

This one looks great.
I'm looking also for a great 433, 4231 and a 4132 narrow

[Lasoneff]

where can I find best ca120/140/160 knap's tactics ? I could not find links for that in excel form.

[knap]

@Lasoneff

They are on ME 23.2 or ME 23.1 Tabs. Unfortunately no links on HUB Test tabs

Easiest way to find them is to sort by name or pts

[knap]

@I.M.F.C

HGF 451 P110 for 433 and US AND THEM 4231.. I don't think I've ever made a 4132 narrow as usually narrow diamond

[knap]

@I.M.F.C

Or a 451 4231 Cross

[knap]

ME 23.2

WHEELS OF FIRE  4231 Skew SS P13

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnap4231SkewSSP103.fmf

[I.M.F.C]

Il y a 16 heures, knap a dit :

@Lasoneff

They are on ME 23.2 or ME 23.1 Tabs. Unfortunately no links on HUB Test tabs

Easiest way to find them is to sort by name or pts

Thanks a lot man.

[I.M.F.C]

Il y a 14 heures, knap a dit :

@I.M.F.C

Or a 451 4231 Cross

you have the link for this one @knap?

[knap]

@I.M.F.C

I will post it this morning

[knap]

ME 23.2

WHEELS OF FIRE 41131 P105 EC CC

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnap41131P105ECCC.fmf

 

[stian]

4 hours ago, knap said:

ME 23.2

WHEELS OF FIRE  4231 Skew SS P13

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnap4231SkewSSP103.fmf 47.33 kB · 23 downloads

@knap Have you tried this in a lower league test?

[knap]

@stian

Nope

[knap]

ME 23.2

WHEELS OF FIRE 41122 P104 FA CC

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnap41122NP104FACC.fmf

[KakaSCP]

what is the top tactic for this version? 424 p107 from hub test not stable 

[knap]

@KakaSCP

It is stable for HUB Test

[KakaSCP]

38 minutos atrás, knap disse:

@KakaSCP

It is stable for HUB Test

you think that still the top tactic ?

[knap]

@KakaSCP

Others may be slightly better, but have not been HUB Tested. 

[knap]

ME 23.2

WHEELS OF FIRE 451 P102 EC CC

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnap451P102ECCC.fmf

[crossroader]

Hello @knap, ive started with Wrexham in National League by using  BEOWULF  BAL SP 424 IF VOL [104 ALL CUPS (never switched to other tactic or different mentality while using it).  Immediately won 1st place in National League, then in League Two, League one and second place in Championship - 4 years in a row it took me to get to Premier league. Broke so many records for Most team goals, Most points and etc, but in my first season in Premier league i finished 12th. My team is with CA 110-130 while im at Premier League (lowest by far compared to other teams), i wanted to switch to similar tactic a little bit more solid defensive, but i struggle to decide which one is good for mid-table team. That formation 424 is really good finding players to suit positions so i dont wanna break the formation, when i looked at hub test it says BEOWULF 424 is best in slot, same in latest ME (p.s my FM23 is update to latest patch and ME). At latest patch sheet most of tactics are tested for top teams Arsenal/Liverpool, are you going to test at least top10  tactics how they perform for mid/low-table teams. It would be good for us your fans to have wider pool of choice. Really appreciate what you are doing, keep the good work! Cheers

 

[knap]

@crossroader

There are a few tests to the right on Docs for Arsenal Everton Havant and West Ham, really just as an indication of what can work. Most of the hard work is done by the player finding the right players.

424 is still one of the top normal  formations. The wide diamond works but uses DWs.

Sort by score to indicate top tactics

 

[crossroader]

Yup gonna give it a try to the new WoF 41212 P106 tactic. Besides that morale/condition and the player position should be as high as possible, do you think player attributes weight is still same as previous FM versions (like last 2-3 years). I still feel pace, acceleration, agility, work rate are still important attributes when chosing the right player. 

p.s i totally agree with that saying that tactic cannot be successful if you dont have proper squad - natural position, good morale, low or now weaknesses, good traits. 

Edited April 14, 2023 by crossroader

[Zlatan11]

On 13/04/2023 at 11:10, knap said:

ME 23.2

WHEELS OF FIRE  4231 Skew SS P13

ME23.2WHEELSOFFIREKnap4231SkewSSP103.fmf 47.33 kB · 79 downloads

Would a AM work instead of SS?