Jump to content

Teams that produce majority foreign newgen players(Update: an actual spreadsheet)

HurkaDurk69
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Popular Post
HurkaDurk69

HurkaDurk69

Posted
  • Popular Post
Posted (edited)

 

@bold013hades has created a spreadsheet for what this thread is about +  some more! I really recommend you checking it out if you like this sort of thread

 

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1JhcGr1klpbLLNtrmufWcIKvWhdOxLwagKpBWaMdyvYA/edit#gid=10819038

Update: I will not update the leagues and divison levels from last year. That was one of the worst things and one of the reason why I stopped caring about this thread, the other was the Turkey update(so, many, 'turk', teams).

Here is an amazing list from  @OlivierL  that have a lot of teams and with facilites, division Level etc etc.

New nationalities and leagues to the list(for FM22) will be marked with blue! No more divisons and division levels for now(maybe never).  Also, I have the real name fix, which means that the name might not be the same in the base game.

 

Warning: You will probably have a hard time reading this because I had a hard time writing this.

FC Andorra in Spain, FC Romania in England, FC Vaduz in Switzerland. They all share something similar between them, they all produce majority newgens that are not from the same nation they compete in.  FC Andorra produces majority Andorran players, FC Romania produces majority Romanian players, and Vaduz produces majority Liechtensteiner players. 

What I mean with majority is not actually the majority, I think it should be around 50% of the intake that should be of said nationality. And I don't count 2nd nationality!

Here are some teams. The big text is the nationality, then it goes (Nation where you can find the team): (Team) (League[Division Level]). I will use * if the team is not in a playable league and ** if the nation is not in the base game.

 

Albania: 

Switzerland: Dardania Basel, Dardania Lausanne, FC Iliria, FC Prishtina Bern

Andorra:

Spain: FC Andorra(Spanish Second Division B3[3])

Bosnia and Herzegovina:

Switzerland: FC Bosna Yverdon

Brazil:

Uruguay: Colina de Rivera, Defensor de Artigas

Brunei: They compete in the Bruneian league, but compete in the singapore cup

Singapore: Duli Pengiran Muda Mahkota FC(Singaporean Premier League[1])

Canada:

USA: Montreal, Vancouver, Toronto

Cape Verde:

Portugal: Africanos Bragança(Portuguese Bragança First Division[4])*

Chile: 

Switzerland: FC Chile Sport

China:

Portugal: Oriental Dragon

Croatia:

Chile: Club Deportivo Sokol(Chilean Amateur Football Association[6])*

Germany: SD Croatia Berlin(German Lower Division[6])*, Croatia Hamburg(German Lower Division[6])*

Switzerland: NK Pajde Möhlin(Swiss Second League Interregio Gr 5[5])*

England:

Scotland: Berwick Rangers(Scottish Lowland League[5])*

Faroe Islands

Denmark: Ítróttarfelagið Føroyar

France:

Scotland: Caledonian Braves(Scottish Lowland League[5])*

Haiti:

Bahamas: Haitian Superstars

Brazil: Academia de Futebol Pérolas Negras(Brazilian National Lower Division[5])*

Turks and Caicos: Flamingo 

Iran:

Philippines: Pasargad Football Club

Ireland:

Australia: Carramar Shamrock Rovers FC

Italy:

Switzerland: FC Azzurri Lausanne, FC Azzurri Bienne, AP Campionese, CS Italien GE

Japan:

Northern Mariana: Okadaya Football Club

Philippines: Manila All-Japan

Singapore: Albirex Niigata (Singapore) FC(Singaporean Premier League[1])

Liechtenstein:

Switzerland: FC Vaduz(Swiss Super League[1]), USV Eschen/Mauren(Swiss First League Group 3[4])*, FC Balzers(Swiss First League Group 3[4])*, FC Schaan(Swiss Lower Division[6])*, FC Triesen(Swiss Lower Division[6])*, FC Ruggell(Swiss Lower Division[6])*, FC Triesenberg(Swiss Lower Division[6])*

Mauritius:

Australia: Endeavour Hills Fire SC

Nepal:

Australia: Darwin Hearts

Northern Ireland

Ireland: Derry City

Peru:

Bonaire: Arriba Perú

Portugal:

Andorra: Fútbol Club Lusitans(Andorran Lower Division[3])**

Luxembourg: RM Hamm Benfica(no longer works in FM2024), Mertzig, Larochette

Saint Barthélemy: ASPSB 

Switzerland: Sport Lausanne Benfica, FC Lusitanos

Romania:

England: FC Romania(English Isthmian League South Central Division[8])*

Italy: Romania Trento(Italian Prima Categoria Trentino Grp. A[7])*

Saint Lucia:

US Virgin Islands: New Vibes

Saint-Martin

Sint Maarten: United Super Stars

San Marino:

Italy: Victor San Marino

Serbia:

Australia: Maddington White City FC

Spain:

Switzerland: FC Espagnol Lausanne

South Korea:

Northern Mariana: Korean Football Association on Saipan(KFAS)

Philippines: General Trias

South Sudan:

Australia: Jaguar FC, Sandown Lions FC

Syria:

Austria: SKV Syrien Wien

Turkey:

Germany: Türkgücü München(3. Liga[3]), Inter Türkspor Kiel(German Div. Schleswig-Holstein[5])*, Türk Gücü Friedberg(German Div. Hessia[5])*, Türkspor Augsburg(German Div. Bavaria South[5])*, FC Türkiye Wilhelmsburg(German Lower Division)*, SC Türkgücü Osnabrück(German Lower Division)*, Türkischer SV Wiesbaden(German Lower Division)*, Türkischer SV Oldenburg(German Lower Division)*, Türk Birlikspor Pinneberg(German Lower Division)*, SV Türkspor Bremen-Nord(German Lower Division)*, BSV Hürtürkel(German Lower Division)*

Wales:

England: Swansea City(Sky Bet Championship[2]), Cardiff City(Sky Bet Championship[2]), Newport County(Sky Bet League Two[4]), Wrexham(Vanarama National League[5]), Merthyr Town(English Southern League Premier South[7])*

 

I will update this thread with teams if I find anything or if any of you reading this know any, then comment the team and I will update it.

I tried to search for this sort of topic but couldn't find any. If there are any, I am sorry.

Edited by HurkaDurk69
Update
12
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 151
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Daveincid

Daveincid

Posted
Posted

In earlier FM's Lusitanos in Andorra always had portuguese youngsters, so you were able to build a worldclass-team with portuguese youngsters due they take the national youth rating from portugal, and not from andorra:brock: It was funny somehow but also not that realistic^^ Maybe something for the bug-forum too for players who like realism (me):D

Cheers

Daveincid

Link to post
Share on other sites
OlivierL

OlivierL

Posted
Posted (edited)
44 minutes ago, XaW said:

@OlivierL - Didn't you compile a list for the youth challenge?

Yes I posted a few other teams like :

Croatia Berlin - Germany - 6th tier - producing Croatian regens only

Caley Braves - Scotland - 5th tier - producing French regens only (played 10 seasons with them).

NK Pajde Möhlin - Switserland - 5th tier - producing Croatian regens only ( not a good choice because of the homegrown rule).

FC Kosova Zürich - Switserland - ?? tier - Producing Albanian or Kosovan regens.

Berwick - Scotland - 5th tier - producing a lot of English regens( they are located in England).

A. Braganca - Portugal - ?? tier - producing Capo Verdeans regens .

Afrika - Iceland - ?? tier - producing many Polish regens , not sure if this is still active.

Oslo City - Norway - ?? tier - produced many African regens but i think this is not the case anymore. I started a save with FC Romania and didn't see many Romanian regens anymore but this was on the beta.

I think that in lower tiers in England , Germany and France u have teams with Polish or brazilian regens but never tested that.

Merthyr - England - 7th tier - producing Welsh regens (located wales but playing in England).

 

Edited by OlivierL
3
Link to post
Share on other sites
XaW

XaW

Posted
Posted

Oslo City does not produce African newgens anymore. And it's quite correct, really. It's a team for the inner city (and have a lot of players with immigrant backgrounds, but not all, and does not differentiate there.

I played lower league in Iceland, and Afrika was there, but they had "no youth recruitment" so no newgens came through, so I don't know if they got in non-Icelandic youngsters. (Quite strange that they get in Polish players when you'd expect it to be more African youngsters? According to this older article, the team should get a "multi-national squad of players based around a core of African players alongside others from countries including Serbia, Portugal and Columbia." - quote from the article).

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Chris Hamilton

Chris Hamilton

Posted
Posted
3 hours ago, UKFA said:

Is there any good way to do this with the editor? Could make for some nice background experiments in a save.

For the Caledonian braves all you would need to do in the editor is search Scottish league 2 then Select one of the teams in that league and hit swap and enter Caledonian braves. Is only moving 1 team between tier 4 & 5 so won’t need to make any other changes as it’s a natural progression. 

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
LC15

LC15

Posted
Posted (edited)
9 hours ago, UKFA said:

Is there any good way to do this with the editor? Could make for some nice background experiments in a save.

Pretty sure if you change the based nation (must be based nation - not nation) for a team to the country you want regens to appear from then it will produce them in game - So hypothetically if you took a premier league team and made them based in spain - it would produce spanish regens. This can only be done in pre game editor - not in game.

Edited by LC15
2
Link to post
Share on other sites
UKFA

UKFA

Posted
Posted
3 hours ago, LC15 said:

Pretty sure if you change the based nation (must be based nation - not nation) for a team to the country you want regens to appear from then it will produce them in game - So hypothetically if you took a premier league team and made them based in spain - it would produce spanish regens. This can only be done in pre game editor - not in game.

Thank you, I'll give that a try.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Ruh Roh

Ruh Roh

Posted
Posted (edited)

Sodertalje FK (Sweden) always produced a ton of Iraqi/Syrian/Turkish players. There might be another club or two in Sweden like that but I know it was Sodertalje for sure. I think they're one division below playable now but you might be able to get them after holidaying a season.

edit: a more obvious one. Turkgucu (German 3 Liga) produces Turkish players

Edited by Ruh Roh
Link to post
Share on other sites
OlivierL

OlivierL

Posted
Posted
On 21/01/2021 at 22:10, Chris Hamilton said:

Caledonian Braves in the Scottish Lowland league (tier5) seem to have a French Link and will bring through french players if promoted to a playable league.

Yes that is what i said :) i played with them on FM20 , +- 10 seasons.

 

Concerning FC Romania i did a new trial with database from Timo (9th tier England) :

They are still producing Romanian regens.

fe905316d1a1d0eba33f4a9313d2bf2f.png
 

2
Link to post
Share on other sites
UKFA

UKFA

Posted
Posted
4 hours ago, Ruh Roh said:

Sodertalje FK (Sweden) always produced a ton of Iraqi/Syrian/Turkish players. There might be another club or two in Sweden like that but I know it was Sodertalje for sure. I think they're one division below playable now but you might be able to get them after holidaying a season.

edit: a more obvious one. Turkgucu (German 3 Liga) produces Turkish players

Assyriska should too, they are a team formed by and for Assyrian expats in Sweden. Assyrians are basically a Christian Orthodox community in Iraq. Strangely, there's two Assyrian teams in Sweden, and the rivalry is apparently very heated!

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
HurkaDurk69

HurkaDurk69

Posted
  • Author
Posted
9 hours ago, UKFA said:

Assyriska should too, they are a team formed by and for Assyrian expats in Sweden. Assyrians are basically a Christian Orthodox community in Iraq. Strangely, there's two Assyrian teams in Sweden, and the rivalry is apparently very heated!

As I Swede, I am ashamed that I forgot about them

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
OlivierL

OlivierL

Posted
Posted (edited)
5 minutes ago, Chris Hamilton said:
12 hours ago, OlivierL said:

Yes that is what i said :) i played with them on FM20 , +- 10 seasons.

Ah so you did! 
How far through the Scottish leagues did you manage to progress to? 

This was the fact file :)

b15d5c437f9e32eca808fdaa1cb55dfa.jpg
 

649a10719af6b34cfe782e78075e3821.png

This was my legend : 

b32ac16ba7f5970554bd8d74acfc4fdc.jpg
 

Edited by OlivierL
1
Link to post
Share on other sites
OlivierL

OlivierL

Posted
Posted
1 minute ago, HurkaDurk69 said:

@OlivierL Was there a reason for why you "only" did 10 seasons?

This was actualy my record since FM16 haha :)

It was diffucult to get my finances right and it was time for something else. But i'm tempted to start again in Scotland (Berwick with English regens) or Caley Braves . but for the youth only challenge (u have to holiday one season) it was very very hard to get them as promoted team. Berwick is no problem.

I could use a custom database and start from day one ..

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
UKFA

UKFA

Posted
Posted

You could also try to resurrect Gretna, which was kind of an irl FM experiment.

I'm doing a background experiment in my FM17 Ghana save (I want to try to win AFCON then see how far I get in the World Cup 2018). I've set up Heart of Midlothian as the senior affiliate to Hearts of Oak and Hearts of Lions (Ghana), Heartland FC (Nigeria), and Real Hearts (SA). I've got all the African leagues loaded anyway for the African Cup of Nations. I'm not sure if it will have much effect, possibly just a few youth players going to the club.

4 hours ago, HurkaDurk69 said:

As I Swede, I am ashamed that I forgot about them

As well you ought to be sir, as well you ought to be!! Just kidding, they're pretty obscure lower division teams I think. I live in Scotland and this is the first I've heard of the Caledonian Braves. For those interested, there's two Assyrian teams, Assyriska and Syrianska, and a team formed by Kurds. I find this stuff really interesting, a club with ties to a different nation. We arguably have that with Celtic FC as well, the name, colours, and history all closely linked to Ireland. Shows how bad Scottish football is when our most successful club is Irish :D

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
OlivierL

OlivierL

Posted
Posted (edited)
17 minutes ago, UKFA said:

You could also try to resurrect Gretna, which was kind of an irl FM experiment.

I'm doing a background experiment in my FM17 Ghana save (I want to try to win AFCON then see how far I get in the World Cup 2018). I've set up Heart of Midlothian as the senior affiliate to Hearts of Oak and Hearts of Lions (Ghana), Heartland FC (Nigeria), and Real Hearts (SA). I've got all the African leagues loaded anyway for the African Cup of Nations. I'm not sure if it will have much effect, possibly just a few youth players going to the club.

As well you ought to be sir, as well you ought to be!! Just kidding, they're pretty obscure lower division teams I think. I live in Scotland and this is the first I've heard of the Caledonian Braves. For those interested, there's two Assyrian teams, Assyriska and Syrianska, and a team formed by Kurds. I find this stuff really interesting, a club with ties to a different nation. We arguably have that with Celtic FC as well, the name, colours, and history all closely linked to Ireland. Shows how bad Scottish football is when our most successful club is Irish :D

Tell me more ? :) 

Maybe u heard about Edusports ? that was the former club / name before fans voted for 'Caley Braves' .

Edited by OlivierL
Link to post
Share on other sites
UKFA

UKFA

Posted
Posted
11 minutes ago, OlivierL said:

Tell me more ? :) 

Basically a lower league club called Gretna FC got a sugardaddy who financed their ascent to the Scottish premier League. Then they went bust, got relegated, then folded soon after. The fans created a phoenix club, 'Gretna 2008', they should still be around somewhere, just waiting for a sugardaddy to bring them back to life.. And of course they'd need a determined manager to help them there!
Gretna is a small town near the border. It was famous for English couples who wanted to get married without their parents permission, the laws in Scotland allowed that so they went across the border to Gretna. It's still used as a bit of a trope, "we'll elope to Gretna". The club actually started off in the English leagues then joined the Scottish league. For that reason some fans of other clubs hated them, as there is a general animosity to all things English up here. Added to this was the fact it's seen as unsporting to simply pump a load of money into a club and win that way, rather than through more organic means. Though some also regarded them as a great success story. As a fan of Heart of Midlothian living in Glasgow at the time, I was surprised by the fact that pretty much everyone (rangers and celtic fans alike) wanted Gretna to beat Hearts in the cup final.

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
UKFA

UKFA

Posted
Posted
36 minutes ago, OlivierL said:

Maybe u heard about Edusports ? that was the former club / name before fans voted for 'Caley Braves' .

I'd never heard of them, but that's really interesting! Maybe one day FM will take these types of training camps into account somehow. Eg if you manage Argentina, and you set up your youth training academy in Uruguay, it has some effect on that region or nation.

Link to post
Share on other sites
OlivierL

OlivierL

Posted
Posted
17 minutes ago, UKFA said:

Basically a lower league club called Gretna FC got a sugardaddy who financed their ascent to the Scottish premier League. Then they went bust, got relegated, then folded soon after. The fans created a phoenix club, 'Gretna 2008', they should still be around somewhere, just waiting for a sugardaddy to bring them back to life.. And of course they'd need a determined manager to help them there!
Gretna is a small town near the border. It was famous for English couples who wanted to get married without their parents permission, the laws in Scotland allowed that so they went across the border to Gretna. It's still used as a bit of a trope, "we'll elope to Gretna". The club actually started off in the English leagues then joined the Scottish league. For that reason some fans of other clubs hated them, as there is a general animosity to all things English up here. Added to this was the fact it's seen as unsporting to simply pump a load of money into a club and win that way, rather than through more organic means. Though some also regarded them as a great success story. As a fan of Heart of Midlothian living in Glasgow at the time, I was surprised by the fact that pretty much everyone (rangers and celtic fans alike) wanted Gretna to beat Hearts in the cup final.

seems very nice , i'll check this. 

Doubting between Caley Braves , Berwick, maybe something like Gretna or starting in Andorra lowest tier.

Link to post
Share on other sites
UKFA

UKFA

Posted
Posted
7 minutes ago, OlivierL said:

seems very nice , i'll check this. 

Doubting between Caley Braves , Berwick, maybe something like Gretna or starting in Andorra lowest tier.

On that theme, check Zealands channel, he's doing a save with Oriental Dragons, which is a Chinese-owned team in the lower leagues of Portugal. They have a club vision which includes bringing in Chinese players. I'm not sure, but In suspect they will generate Chinese or 2nd nationality Chinese newgens as well.

2
Link to post
Share on other sites
shimera

shimera

Posted
Posted
7 minutos atrás, CoffeeFueledCurmudgeon disse:

How exactly do they get Romanian regens then? It's not because they have a 'based nation' difference?

image.thumb.png.ee6d4af73c61939811b9484cd45f0cf8.png

They are hardcoded in the database to get dual nationality newgens, though you can emulate that with a city that has a foreign "local region" set in the pre-game FM Editor

Link to post
Share on other sites
UKFA

UKFA

Posted
Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, shimera said:

They are hardcoded in the database to get dual nationality newgens, though you can emulate that with a city that has a foreign "local region" set in the pre-game FM Editor

So say for example I wanted to get some Russian newgens at Chelsea occasionally, I would create a new city, put its local region as a Russian region like Siberia or something, and its nation as England? EDIT: and of course set Chelseas location to this new cty

Edited by UKFA
clarification
Link to post
Share on other sites
shimera

shimera

Posted
Posted
3 minutos atrás, UKFA disse:

So say for example I wanted to get some Russian newgens at Chelsea occasionally, I would create a new city, put its local region as a Russian region like Siberia or something, and its nation as England? EDIT: and of course set Chelseas location to this new cty

From my experience that would make most newgen players dual nationals (English/Russian)

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
OlivierL

OlivierL

Posted
Posted

Just holidayed one season with Caley Braves (database from Timo) : 

In my ten seasons with them on FM20 , they only had french regens (one or two from marroco) and some second African nationalities .

Now i see a good mix from Scottish and French regens:

5d99661e04bb2741ac897d5519f8f107.png
 

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
HurkaDurk69

HurkaDurk69

Posted
  • Author
Posted
5 minutes ago, OlivierL said:

Just holidayed one season with Caley Braves (database from Timo) : 

In my ten seasons with them on FM20 , they only had french regens (one or two from marroco) and some second African nationalities .

Now i see a good mix from Scottish and French regens:

5d99661e04bb2741ac897d5519f8f107.png
 

It might have to do with Brexit(IDK if Scotland have the same 17 foreign player limit that England has since I never have them loaded)

Link to post
Share on other sites
UKFA

UKFA

Posted
Posted
13 minutes ago, OlivierL said:

Just holidayed one season with Caley Braves (database from Timo) : 

In my ten seasons with them on FM20 , they only had french regens (one or two from marroco) and some second African nationalities .

Now i see a good mix from Scottish and French regens:
 

That seems to be the case in real life too, I suspect they have squad rules for foreign players in the league.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caledonian_Braves_F.C.#Current_squad

Link to post
Share on other sites
OlivierL

OlivierL

Posted
Posted
On 18/01/2021 at 19:15, Daveincid said:

In earlier FM's Lusitanos in Andorra always had portuguese youngsters, so you were able to build a worldclass-team with portuguese youngsters due they take the national youth rating from portugal, and not from andorra:brock: It was funny somehow but also not that realistic^^ Maybe something for the bug-forum too for players who like realism (me):D

Cheers

Daveincid

Just checked this. The team now calls Lusitans FC and they play in the third tier. Andorra custom database have 2 tiers with no relegation so they aren't playable.

They seem to get some Portugese guys :) 

2
Link to post
Share on other sites
HurkaDurk69

HurkaDurk69

Posted
  • Author
Posted
23 minutes ago, OlivierL said:

Just checked this. The team now calls Lusitans FC and they play in the third tier. Andorra custom database have 2 tiers with no relegation so they aren't playable.

They seem to get some Portugese guys :) 

Thank you:thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites
UKFA

UKFA

Posted
Posted

Other possibilities (but I haven't checked them)
Palestino in Chile, may produce Palestinian nationality players as the club is associated with Chilean Palestinians
Cyprus - some clubs are associated with Greek players, and others with Turkish
LAFC and Inter Miami - it may be that these teams and other MLS teams produce a high number of latino second nationalities due to the demographics
 

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
HurkaDurk69

HurkaDurk69

Posted
  • Author
Posted
20 minutes ago, UKFA said:

Other possibilities (but I haven't checked them)
Palestino in Chile, may produce Palestinian nationality players as the club is associated with Chilean Palestinians
Cyprus - some clubs are associated with Greek players, and others with Turkish
LAFC and Inter Miami - it may be that these teams and other MLS teams produce a high number of latino second nationalities due to the demographics
 

Good shouts about Palestino and the MLS teams, unfortunately it yielded zero results :(

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
HurkaDurk69

HurkaDurk69

Posted
  • Author
Posted
56 minutes ago, bielsadidnothingwrong said:

I love this thread not only for the FM-value, but I have not heard of some of these clubs in real life and love hearing about them and their community ties!

 

54 minutes ago, OlivierL said:

This isn't the first topic about this kind of teams but this seems the most active one ! i like it  :) 

Cheers lads, it means a lot

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 months later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...