[[France] Data Issues]

38 分钟前, AlienIR说:

Hi @dongjianjian1 

I'm not sure that 165 is a realistic PA for Faivre... Not claiming he's not a good player having a good season in Brest... Same with a -85 PA, it's really strong for a player, who is doing good surely, but also a player who is just playing his first season as a professional player.

 

 

Same here, not claiming he's not a strong prospect and his current PA is perfect, far from it, but I disagree with the suggestion and the reason for this request.

 

 

Unfortunately, we come to the point, I've to remind the opening post:  Data is subjective. Please keep the thread for real data issues (eg Player's in wrong club, wrong position, foot and so on). Discussion around CA/PA are just a bit useless because: 

- 1) CA/PA are subjective

-2) We are in the process of the winter update, with the full team reviewing CA/PA of the players/ team they are following.  Those again would be reviewed by the end of the season and before next release...

- 3) We follow French football: I think we are aware of Simakan/ Faivre/ Truffert's and many more performances....

 

You may disagree with our ratings, which is fine, as we may disagree with your suggestions and won't follow them if we think they are not appropriate. CA/PA discussions are just a loss off time and energy as they are likely to be subjective.

 

I hope the feedback would help. I simply want to keep the thread as much readable as possible.

Best regards

Thank you very much for your reply. But I don't quite agree with you.
1) I think it's useful to talk about CA / PA because football manager is a data and tactical game. The players' data is important.
2) Although Ca / PA is a very subjective thing, you don't have to take other people's opinions. But it can be used as a reference.
Thank you for the game you made for us.

[[Portugal] Data Issues]

 Pedro Porro PA 154.It is reasonable to receive the influence of injury before. But Pedro Porro has recovered well from the injury. Now sports CP ranks first in the Liga NOS and has reached the final of the Portuguese League Cup. Pedro Porro is the absolute main force, and the performance is also very good. Attached is a screenshot of whoscored's ratings. Considering that he is only 21 years old, I think his PA should be given 160.

[[Germany Bundesliga] Data Issues]

Matthew Hoppe PA 112 is too low. I think he should be -9 。Although Schalke 04 is likely to be relegated this season, the haze of Schalke 04 can not cover up Hoppe's three consecutive goals. And Hoppe is 191cm tall。Hope Hoppe will update your data in a patch. thank you.

[[England Premier Division] Data Issues]

Mount PA 168 is too low. I think he should be 175 or more. First of all, he just had his 22nd birthday, very young. Second, although the result of Chelsea is worse, but mount is undoubtedly the most dazzling one. Also, he has the attribute of iron man and never gets hurt. He trains hard and runs and presses tirelessly in the game. He can adapt to any coach, any tactics, his future is limitless.

[[Italy] Data Issues]

Why did Nicolo barella's PA drop to 168? I think his PA should be 175. As a midfield player, Nicolo barella has scored two goals and seven assists so far this season. On the football field, he can score goals, assist and have enough physical strength to press and defend. Inter Milan can get the current second place, he has a lot of credit. His strength is no worse than that of Artur and milenkovic. According to Italian football market network Nicolo barella's excellent performance has attracted the attention of Tottenham Hotspur and Liverpool.

[[France] Data Issues]

Adrien truffert pa - 7 is too low, should be - 85. Adrien truffert has occupied the main force of Rennes left-back in the 20-21 season. And it's amazing.He's only 19 years old. I think it should be corrected in the next patch.

[[France] Data Issues]

Romain Faivre PA 132 is too low，should be  165.

I have three reasons.

First of all, he is Brest's best player, as shown in the picture.

Second, he has passed 52 times this season and is number one in the French premier league.

Finally, according to the French media Le 10sport, he has been followed by Paris Saint Germain and Manchester United.

[[France] Data Issues]

Adrien truffert pa - 7 is too low, should be - 85. Adrien truffert has occupied the main force of Rennes left-back in the 20-21 season. And it's amazing.He's only 19 years old. I think it should be corrected in the next patch.

[Football Manager 2019 Official Feedback Thread]

Why is Kalidou Koulibaly only 187 centimeters height?