What on earth merits Hammarby having the best academy in FM24 then?
Top 3 is irrelevant. Dovin should not in any sense be considered a "star" in Allsvenskan. He's a decent keeper at Allsvenskan level, nothing more. Same with Erabi, who has 1 good summer at Allsvenskan level, yet is top Allsvenskan level in key stats and mentals.
Again, top 5 is irrelevant. They are to highly rated compared to the average Allsvenskan player. Hammarby has all seasons except for 2022 been a poor defensive side which I would argue that that was due to Marti's good tactics rather than player quality.
That's good, but their youth players are still highly rated, especially in role scores. As we see with Turkish players this year, CA is not everything.