Jump to content

  • Very few yellow cards an red cards in almost every league after 24.2.0 too

    Cle

    By Cle

      • Files Uploaded: Save Game Public Status: Under Review Save Game: Update test 07
     Share

    Description of issue

    Antecedent: 

    I tested 11 leagues now with full details for 5 years. The differences are very large. (IRL vs FM24). I found a league where there are more than 900!!!!!! yellow cards less in a league.

    Red card= (1 red and 2 yellow too)

                  Yellow    Red           IRL 21/22        IRL 22/23    
    Spain 1.    842    16                1866    92    1772    139
    Spain 2.    852    14                2092    107    2207    152
    Portugal 1.    718    30           1677    116    1550    111
    Portugal 2.    558    8             1647    102    1612    98
    Holland 1.    652    13            872    45    860    41
    Holland 2.    641    16            1001    34    1193    55
    Italy 1.    1175    42                1686    92    1628    68
    Italy 2.    902    18                  1857    93    1786    111
    Germany 1.    836    28         1051    24    1197    43
    Germany 2.    662    22         1203    41    1260    59
    Germany 3.    705    13         1547    58    1669    78
    France 1.    730    24              1182    99    1390    103 (with 20 teams, but the difference is still huge)
    France 2.    565    22             1326    86    1328    91
    France 3.    391    10             1157    98    1090    95
    England 1.    977    31           1290    43    1353    30
    England 2.    1253    35        1997    70    2049    65
    England 3.    1303    40        1900    76    1947    81
    England 4.    1187    36        1824    92    1850    69
    Belgium 1.    601    10          1242    89    1149    87
    Austria 1.    348    9              767    42    721    41
    Austria 2.    391    4              1071    64    1035    52
    Denmark 1.    352    10        515    14    482    20
    Scottish 1.    496    15          767    46    763    55
    Scottish 2.    374    7            563    22    656    31
    Scottish 3.    291    9            622    48    611    33
    Scottish 4.    281    9            588    32    705    45

    Why are so many yellow and red cards missing? Goalkeeper cards are also missing, but this is about 5%. Can you increase the number of cards with next patch?

    FM 24 yellow.jpg

     Share
    Go to issues

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    RDF Tactics
    On 25/02/2024 at 07:21, clelikeweeweetoomuch said:

    What the hell ?!

    I had to create an account just because of this post.

    You are something special. Lesser than any other living form.

    Why would it be a bug? Why would FM be realistic? What iteration of FM since it creation in 1994 had achieve realism? How can computer science replicate any of football aspect to match reality when it is lacking every tool for it? 

    If anything, in fm24 your team get book more often than "in real life". Why would you aggregate results from AI? 

    Really. Apart from nourrishing your projections and god complex. Why would you want FM to be realistic?
    Because of posts like this and "humans" like you FM 24 is already a snooze fest. You can't take your small town club and make it a champion's league winner thanks to tactical exploits. Tactics and management never matter less than it does in fm24. These two things are the only player interactions in the game. You now have to take sweet years on your save to "build" a "process" made 99.99% about random luck. Moral/Club reputation/Player traits are the only thing that matter.

    Now here's the thing: to witness boring 0-0 or soulcrushing loss I have real life and the team I support for this. Why whould I need to endure that in a video game?


    When "humans" like you claim FM is realistic or a simulation it just tell the rest of the real humans two things: 1. you clearly know nothing about computer science and the tricks used by devs to replicate randomness. Because there are more chances a computer will be able to divide by 0, find the last digit of pi, and what not than achieving the mathematical equation of randomness.
    2. If FM is anything close to a simulation. Then it is made for a playerbase compose of Mourinho and Guardiola. I hate it to bring it to you, because it is this false god complex that make you have these claims. But we all are horrible, absolute doodoo as manager. If any of us would take control of Man City we would crash it into sunday league.

    Have a nice "life".

     

    really, no need for that condescending message.

    So according to you, everyone should enjoy FM (and football) the same way? You ask whats the fun in a soul-crushing 0-0 but that is EXACTLY what some people want to do. Quite literally.

    Many FM players appreciate good defensive work. So, why can't you take your small town club to the Champions League by playing the football you want to? Why does it have to be high-scoring (or whatever) games? Why should you not be able to create something that, if done well, can get you to win games 1-0, 2-0 without 20 shots a game etc?

    1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    RDF Tactics
    39 minutes ago, toilet said:

    Can you read ?

    1. The entire SI team and this forum is condescending trolls who have nothing else to do than simping this game telling people "it's a tactic problem".


    2. My point with the 0-0 is that SI was forcefeeding their vision of football. They want to balance this video games, limiting tactical exploit for the sake of a "simulation" never ever achieved in that game. 


    3."Many FM players appreciate good defensive work". You got me. Defense barrely ever work in FM. Actually the only way to defend since the new match engine is to attack. Much delusion here.


    4. You can't take your small club and win the champions league because SI decided to. It has nothing to do with tactic. If you take any random top tactic out there and apply it to you lower league team: you'll get crushed. FM never been a simulation. It is a management game. Before there were "tactical" matters. Now there is no more. Before you could build a tactic and have instant results in game. Now you will have to wait for your team to win lower leagues, make a name in the middle/top of the elite division. You'll have to get good runs in international competitions. In other words you'll have to wait for club rep/player moral/squad cohesion to lign up. Reducing tactic and player interaction to the least relevant aspect of the game. You as a player are the least impacting aspect of FM 24. 

    You like to eat ****. I don't. Again. It is a video game. I'm not here to be bored. It cannot and will never simulate football. There is absolutely no reason to ask for more cards. You're both sore losers. If any of you took the headcoach of mancity you'll make it a sunday league mid table team. Shake your desilusion off.

    what are you talking about? :lol: 

    I'm praying you're not an adult. Also hope you're not a role model to anyone at this moment if this is how you communicate to people. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...