Jump to content

Life in Red & White - A Tribute to One of the Pioneers of Moneyball in Football: Croatia


shaunvamos
 Share

Recommended Posts

my-life-in-red-and-white.jpg

 

Arsène Wenger.

 

The longest serving and most successful manager Arsenal has ever had, and arguably one of the best managers of all time. 

 

I've been an Arsenal fan since I was 7, so when I found his autobiography in a bookstore I knew I just had to buy it. 

 

Everyone knows about his investment in youth development, and how his shrewd spending kept the club afloat during the clubs move to the Emirates from Highbury. He's actually one of the few Premier League managers in the modern era to actually turn a profit on transfers, which only adds to his reputation as a talent spotter and bargain hunter. These are both philosophies I pride myself on when playing this game. 

 

But there was one thing that stood out to me while reading this book (I haven't finished it yet) about a method he used while at Monaco. I'll let his words do the talking (p92):

Quote

"We also made a lot of use - and were the first to do so - of a clever method of evaluation developed by my friend Jean-Marc Guillou.

Top Score is a tool for evaluating players based on observing and quantifying their performances. You assign points for each action the player carries out - for example, ten points for a forward pass, five for a sideways pass, two for a back pass - and you establish a defensive score and an offensive score which you add up."

 

This sounds an awful lot like the methodologies I've used to great success in my FM22 save documented on these forums, using players in game attributes to calculate scores and evaluate their ability and role suitability. But Wenger doesn't stop there...

 

Quote

"President Campora, Jeannot Petit and I also realised what an opportunity Top Score represented on the transfer market. We knew Monaco had less money than PSG and Marseille or some of the big European clubs. We managed our finances sensibly, unlike those clubs who had taken on on whole new financial dimension. We needed to buy players but at a price we could afford, and we needed to find cheaper solutions. With the Top Score indicators we could buy players who had not yet been spotted and courted by other clubs. This also allowed us to give our own young players from the training academy their chance."

 

Sounds a lot like Moneyball.....

 

Again, I combined these two elements in my FM22 save where I won the Champions League in 9 countries using a team from the lowest playable division. But this time I want to do something even more ambitious and probably impossible.

 

The goal is simple.

Win the Champions League.  

With every nation possible.

That's right, leagues from all 210 nations have been loaded. How many are eligible for a Champions League? I guess I'll find out!

 

Rules

1. Start with the highest ranked nation in the world rankings. This will not include England, Spain, Germany, Italy, France, Netherlands, Portugal, Scotland and Austria as I've already achieved the feat with them.

 2. With the lowest possible qualifications, take over the team predicted to finish the worst in the lowest playable division on the condition that the team's colours include RED & WHITE. This is a nod to Wenger, who only managed teams with those colours in them.

3. Only sign players that can better the first XI, and only in the event that they are under 23. If that can't be done, we rely on our youth academy, which means upgrades will be a priority. The recruitment and selection of these players will be determined using my attribute formula created and stored in a spreadsheet.

4. Where I sign players from is based on my boards discretion. I can only scout in my country? We'll only sign players based there. They're letting us scout players based in our region? So be it. Worldwide scouting you say? Beautiful. 

5. The number of leagues that will be loaded at any one time will include nations that border the nation I am currently managing in. In the event of a nation that is landlocked, an island, or with less than 5 border countries the closest 5 will be made playable. For example, the 5 closest nations to Iceland will be made playable when I get to Iceland. 

6. Winning the top division league title unlocks international management for that nation. What this means is that I will manually sack the national team manager by adding a new manager, then resigning allowing my actual manager to apply for the role. 

7. Win the country's respective Champions League!

8. Once the CL is won I move on to the team ranked highest in the world rankings that I haven't managed in yet. The leagues used for the previous nation will be deactivated and made View Only, unless that completed nation is in Europe. In that case the top league will be kept as playable and the rest will be View Only. This is done for two reasons: I love the UEFA coefficient system so it would be interesting to follow the clubs I've managed there, but doing this for every other continent would slow the game down to no end. 

9. Tactics: There will be no set formation. I will use whatever formation my analyst thinks is best against our next opposition. In terms of instructions I will simply be using the default Gegenpress instructions. The roles will be as simple as they come: Goalkeeper, Central Defender, Full Back, Wing Back, Defensive Midfielder, Winger, Central Midfielder, Winger, Attacking Midfielder, and Advanced Forward.

 

 

I've rambled on for long enough. Let's get this started!

 

 

 

Acknowledgements

 

This wouldn't be possible without the incredible work of people who made all these leagues playable. All the standard leagues are loaded as well as the following:

@Timo61, who made every unplayable league in this playable except 23 at this point!

Tenshi on the Steam Workshop, who provided Paraguay, Costa Rica, Tajikistan, Thailand, Somalia and Moldova.

Riddler on the Steam Workshop, who provided British Virgin Islands, Sudan, Jamaica, Solomon Islands, Azerbaijan, Palestine, Benin, Togo and the Dominican Republic.

@Scorrie1893 who provided San Marino.

Bartolomeus on the Steam Workshop, who provided Jordan, the UAE, Syria and Turks & Caicos. 

SI who provided Gibraltar.

Reinalda on the Steam Workshop who provided Vanuatu.

AGE Interactive on the Steam Workshop, who provided Albania.

 

Edited by shaunvamos
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 287
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

image.jpeg.0197ad2f25a35d5cc0d82ce22a2166c0.jpeg

 

Nation One: Brazil

 

6e6b50238aae86919742a5efca4d583f.png

 

 

 

7cf6c8e7bf1e9ecf6ae5f79459a3b672.png
 

 

 

 

af20ab75a5c1b3ce5d6a372cfad1f85e.png
 

 

 

 

5eeb46aa8767d19ef401220c56d838bb.png
 

 

 

Brazil, a country I have never managed in (I suspect there will be a lot of this). Clearly one of the best ever talent producing nations, so let's see what we can do here!

 

 

 

3dde4baa6d23143dbb36051ee1929928.png
 

 

There doesn't seem to be too much pressure on us here in terms of expectations, and the board just want me to avoid bottom.

 

 

 

2a42a45a19c2cbc945d398bb967a1603.png
 

 

An average wage on 1464 a month means we can probably make some additions to the squad, but not many. As expected, we'll only be signing players based in Brail for now.

 

 

 

Leagues loaded: Brazil, Argentina, Paraguay, Uruguay, Bolivia, Peru, Colombia, Venezuela, Guyana and Suriname.

Edited by shaunvamos
Link to post
Share on other sites

January 2022

 

ec0af3f5606b66d50ce3e0659c3d95a9.png
 

We bring in a goalkeeper as we didn't have one. No other transfers will be sought after as everyone's demands are too high for what we can afford right now.

 

 

 

b43112a26b63c04c5315d2a67ad574c6.png
 

 

 

 

65c46d2527c2f241ce41ff3fc0746d29.png
 

 

 

 

67ddc8be4acc46ed5649c563c05ff849.png
 

 

A mixed start to my tenure here, but it looks like we'll be able to qualify from this first stage.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • shaunvamos changed the title to Life in Red & White - A Tribute to One of the Pioneers of Moneyball in Football

July 2022

 

32e4dceaae16c15a7a2edbd7f0ccb37d.png
 

 

We found a lot of good bargains in this transfer window, 3 free loans as well as free transfers with all but two earning less than 1k/m.

 

 

 

Central Defender

 

039d7c7e49d1ec9c047efa0933159c0f.png

 

 

 

Fullback

 

20dfd56e0254b0eff0907491e63b50e2.png
 

 

 

 

Defensive Midfielder

 

7c59d8291f13f835772dbad2cd4cae11.png
 

 

 

 

Central Midfielders

 

699a7e80babc800b2cc779f8b1406e5a.png
 

 

5d91bad0d65d956b4ac35b0ae5c6bbc9.png
 

 

 

 

Wingers

 

2125edadeee5f2d0c98f53152c69414f.png

 

 

616a1406808f14279f9cea95565b77f2.png
 

 

 

Attacking Midfielder

 

bd612631a4ecc6f87dcf1f10e380c4d6.png
 

 

 

 

Striker

 

1352e15dbdcede615dc6afd184cf10c7.png
 

 

 

 

3cb09affa4ec057f92dcd6bb1cc2d18d.png
 

 

299002add7a21aba6a7b1e6e1399c222.png
 

 

We seem to have forgotten how to score, but hopefully that changes once the new additions settle in.

Link to post
Share on other sites

September 2022

 

ca73ff1ee31088456ab9868cac27aacf.png
 

 

bebf18e1dafb521229978b7a91542d97.png
 

 

A 3-0 win sours our time in the Third Division, but we scrape into the Second Stage on goal difference where the top two in each group get promotion. We've gone 1-1 in our first two, but I'm not expecting we'll get top 2.

Link to post
Share on other sites

659d3e34faf02bcd0f7a3a58671e745c.png
 

 

 

 

a31ec0c312578cbe5a7f8daa863da02b.png
 

 

Sao Jose completely destroy us, so surely we didn't get promoted.

 

 

 

8f78acb11fa1b0ca64f42da1f11696b3.png
 

 

But we did :D From the board hoping we didn't finish bottom to actually getting promoted on the final day, this save has gotten off to a banger of a start.

 

 

 

Best XI

 

4f2d362ce004e66f73ebee7db7843e65.png
 

 

Lucas Concatto  -  Lucão  -  Lionn

 

 

 

ecb9f60532c180ce0314e942d5642c3c.png
 

 

 

 

Record Breakers

 

6f467461aa09f0dc367aa7d103b6ee4f.png
60f4955ed29fc9f12cbf779e97f3b2f9.png
 

 

 

 

Award Winners

 

4ed268a7a846312dada2177373d7c4b5.png
 

 

 

 

Supporter Profile

 

bd77d81900788de7799845e8c1243c96.png
 

 

Looks like we're becoming a more family oriented club at the expense of the ultras :D

 

 

 

1f850d87ede46e8fdf6b18b8cfc97859.png
 

 

There's also this, a wage budget more than 4 times our budget at the beginning of the season. Some of that will be moved to the transfer budget of course, but it should be a lot easier to sign some players to bolster our squad for next season.

 

 

 

Dynamic Manager Timeline

 

 

 

 

 

 

Progress

 

1e4732a463c8f0a2bb2b79c8eaae518a.png
 

Link to post
Share on other sites

January 2023

 

10c7cffa749f05c11779fdd1706c29da.png
 

 

Having been blessed with a huge increase in wage budget, we used that to recruit an upgrade in all but 2 positions. Of those brought in 3 came from our division or higher. Let's hope they don't find the step up too intimidating.

 

 

 

Keeper

 

a1f7e880adbe99acc414f677e6e68457.png
 

 

 

 

Fullbacks

 

951f1b653e28a1f6647c3c7c678939ba.png
 

 

d669ab6db08da5deb544a2388810f052.png
 

 

 

 

Defensive Midfielder

 

e13d834b4383784242554ac3262191f0.png
 

 

 

 

 

Central Midfielders

 

16b4e9a135f71821cdb8b68eeda3ae0f.png
 

 

ba1759cfa44fda5fed7deebf336bf58d.png
 

 

 

Winger

 

9e81095f848931bed4c00c391e3d5822.png
 

 

 

 

Attacking Midfielder

 

5645e7db5bb3b59c97ef2ab22b741b62.png
 

 

 

 

Striker

 

465f667aec3a0460fc7cc8ed2f3c616a.png
 

 

 

 

c38bf4bf505ce6650ca5d82511bbb01b.png
 

 

2133328e9d9d359ff79c4aca0350712c.png
 

 

3122d040d938a6747b33e72379814a3c.png
 

 

I'm not sure what to make of things yet, but now the full team is in place I'll be able to have a better gauge of things.

Link to post
Share on other sites

July 2023

 

72a271014ce77de96c1dd76ff4edd402.png
 

 

Two more additions, but only Wagninho can play as Thassio has made too many appearances in the Second Division for another team.

 

 

 

Defensive Midfielder

 

add31e71beecbca586ef70912d1ed678.png
 

 

 

 

24713ced7b0c39065dfbf69e6442564e.png

 

 

 

69d56b903ed2fb058653befc2ac64f4b.png
 

 

Another mixed month, but survival is the only priority here.

Link to post
Share on other sites

January 2024

 

1c66ca137748d38173cd5a460be95eb1.png
 

 

Only three additions this season, but they're good ones.

 

 

 

Central Defender

 

b4f522a56996ee7cdca001c49858e385.png
 

 

 

 

Defensive Midfielder

 

2b0075f7f9dcd719352ad3577058186c.png
 

 

 

 

 

Winger

 

761adab3f982e8ccdf785233858419a0.png
 

 

 

 

152168e5de5fd6608567c1474be8e45c.png
 

 

We're dropping results to teams two divisions below us, so I'm treating all of this as a preseason friendly series.

Link to post
Share on other sites

March 2024

 

20c0ac361940ddc23b527af811d29b15.png
 

 

Another busy month, but we've been thankfully knocked out of the NE Regional and probably will be in the State champs too. In other news we've finally won our first Brazilian Cup match, and then we won our second! Bring on the matches that actually mean something!

Link to post
Share on other sites

April 2024

 

ac1cdbb003670538da200ab4c828245b.png
 

 

43ceb2f21ee2cd70c9aa81258bdb225e.png
 

 

We ended up making the semi of the State Cup before losing to 5 time defending champions Fortaleza, but we get off to a good start in the league after losing to one of the few teams I actually know in Bahia. I also know two other teams that were relegated to the 2nd division for this season in Cruzeiro and Vasco da Gama.

Link to post
Share on other sites

2024 Youth Intake

 

4a070e5d3b6b64eeb73cd12415e16e1a.png
 

 

Rodrigo 3A*  -  Gabriel Volpe 3B*  -  Edney 3C

 

 

fd6db0f783e195dd49de98ee17d160c6.png
 

 

This is pretty disappointing, but it's mainly due to the board refusing to upgrade our coaching because "we have enough youth players, make use of them". Quality over quantity mate, seriously :seagull: At least we have our first interstate player.

 

 

 

31803596a81ca29a2465c2263682d9a2.png
 

 

 

 

c8370be8ca3c8b7283b87103196ae23e.png
 

Link to post
Share on other sites

a5ded164668bbd5a5710fea77dc20c4f.png
 

 

288b289a2e9852e9d71e3ab87f2e1db3.png
 

 

d7db18b55e2fcaa07902b7647344de85.png
 

 

We did our absolute best to bottle it, but we steadied the ship in our final game to get promoted. We're going to the Brasileirão!

 

 

 

Best XI

 

7e5639d0187ea2b41d8ba0d91503b4f5.png
 

 

Jobert  -  José Hugo  -  Fernandinho

 

 

 

a97e886d729fb263ba122c65a435f1fa.png
 

 

 

 

image.thumb.png.b39555f3c55bf9836bdefd2517826fee.png

 

 

 

 

Record Breakers

 

9863df33b994d622b4e250736387d638.png
2ab95709721900aaa6445a23b55a8700.png
 

 

 

 

Award Winners

 

27d8d4f8c1bb16618c101902c0d87547.png
 

 

 

 

Progress

 

6f1d256f88c21fe2805212e0f27ba9b7.png
 

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

January 2025

 

04847fd33dab5b906363c2c34f382830.png
 

 

I really wish FM had an option to show future fees in brackets, because we only spent about half that up front. We've bought our first newgens as well, and they're excellent. Cerqueira is a U20 international playing the Third Division, Sarahyba in the Fourth Division, and Elton is a huge steal from perennial league contenders Corinthians.

 

 

 

Central Defender

 

d009043d74022e60c608ba282d2b0de8.png
 

 

 

 

Fullback

 

e75967dac64c47c1a6f9cc4ee61d09d6.png
 

 

 

 

Central Midfielder

 

7aeb79e69cf37944594afc94db11e816.png
 

 

 

 

Winger

 

ab36fe0e024f779d82238595a263c38c.png
 

 

 

 

Striker

 

e7463edabb7c52cc333e2cd65b3a66a6.png
 

 

 

 

 

c6a80e07125bb797e3d1a504f8194885.png
 

 

5e666c115c85d1b2313aaeb05a027b34.png
 

 

A slow start that's already been ridden with injuries, but as soon as the new signings joined we've had a change in fortunes. But we really should be beating teams 2 divisions below us.

 

 

 

On 29/11/2022 at 23:31, Emozil said:

Great write up so far. What tactic are you using? I'm having a lot of success with 2 defensive mid tactics this year too. Hoping yours is easy on the eye with you being in Brazil. :) 

 

Just the generic Gegenpress.

Edited by shaunvamos
Link to post
Share on other sites

May 2025

 

12a807a5ddd0001b37ada07bc73a4859.png

 

682be2db6922753b6e7cb70c5c350b50.png

 

As expected, we're struggling in the league, but we won the State title for the first time since 1995! Elton is scoring plenty too, and I just read that he's supposed to be the next Jairzinho, a World Cup winner for Brazil in 1970 as part of his 81 caps and 33 goals for them. He even managed Gabon from 2003-2005!

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...