ATW
Members+-
Posts
4,595 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Reputation
273 "I mean, funny like I'm a clown? I amuse you?"About Me
-
About Me
Motherwell FC Researcher (living in Livingston)
Recent Profile Visitors
The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.
-
The FM23 Youth Academy Challenge
ATW replied to darren1983's topic in Challenges, Sign-Ups & Experiments
Congrats @the_hdk Winter has come(and gone), so it is time to try this again! Off to Brazil. Started the 2023 season so Re-Set date is 3 January 2024 Brasiliense Futebol Clube I also have the transfers due in. A keeper, I will try not to use him, BUT I have only 1 keeper in the squad (a 16 year old fresh face) so I can not be sure that will happen -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
There is... 3 Rangers, 2 Aberdeen and Celtic, 1 Hearts, 1 Motherwell and 1 Hibernian... -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
So... lets see, if there was some sort of list kept every season... -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
No mention of too many Celtic players in top 5 though... why, is that? -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
Do you believe Kyogo is far to good for Celtic? Do you believe he is by far the best Japanese Striker in the World? -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
No, you have provided attribute numbers, without taking into account what they do when put altogether. Not to mention not taking into consideration real life performances. Kyogo, isn't devastating because of his raw finishing ability, but because of his sublime movement, and the tactics Celtic employ to get the very best out of him. If anything that's where you you should be questioning, have we got this part of his game right? As for proof. I ran a 2x 1 season test and Kyogo topped the goal scoring charts in both, with in 1 no player getting within 15 goals of him in the league. What in game tests have you ran? -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
Hi. Thank you for post, but your conclusion is incorrect. Kyogo finishing ability is higher than Morelos' in game. Have you run tests, by playing as both Rangers and Celtic, and as well as letting AI do it's thing. -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
We have tbf already said we'd look at moving CalMac to 18, for AI purposes but 16 still makes him the best DMC in the league, by quite a margin. The AML/R is not Left Winger/Right Winger in the true sense. As you will notice a true winger will have the ML/R filled in, Kyogo does not. What it represents is he's an attacker who can play right across the line rather than just a CF Fair points tbf. -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
Because he played 14 league games this season FFS. It's a winter update -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
No he didn't. But thanks for playing. -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
Good to know you watched a lot of Pro-League football as well as J-League. -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
But we don't just compare CA numbers as it means f-all. But tbh, No idea, he's only played 90 minutes of Scottish football - most of which against a Championship Side already losing 4-0. -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
DMC - Levitt 104 DMC - Iwata - 120 Now... sit down and learn what you're looking at. -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
16 points better CA for same position is not a similar CA. It's a whole level above. Now learn what you're looking at when discussing CA and attributes when comparing players please. A good start would be for the love of God reading @Giro's two posts on player ratings. Then we can maybe discuss it. -
cinch Premiership Data discussion
ATW commented on Ed Hewison's issue in [Scotland] Premiership Data Issues
I'm so glad you watched a lot of the J-League - and you put so much stock into POY awards, as I've said forever, in their primes Michael Higdon was a far superior striker to Leigh Griffiths (I haven't really). As for Campbell, he a very solid, if unspectacular player, who is right in the middle of the pack of decent Scottish Premiership players Don't, please. If you wanna question it, come with substance we can look at, but comparing two players, from diffetent positions is a no.