Thanks Marc for the elaborate responses! I understand some of the background mechanisms much better now.
When it comes to the cases where you seek examples I’ll report it next time I see something representative.
I do agree with above posters that loading more famous players and wonderkids would really enhance the experience, and it wouldn’t be so hard to hide that from casual users by mechanisms we find in other games in the series - such as indicating performance impact of a large selection or if that’s infeasible at least expand the number of players loaded from non-selected leagues a bit further without additional options presented.
Good to hear there are mechanisms for potentials to shift mid-game, I would enjoy it being a more frequent event though as I’ve never encountered a Luca Toni or James Vardy while playing.
I still think the ratings in midfield and *-impact from youths trying out senior football still needs tweaking. Even global superstars struggle to get 7 average rating as CM’s currently, while a player like Endrick would still be considered a wonderkid even if he were to start his Real Madrid career with some brief substitutions of little impact.
Using fake players really only does change the names for me. Trying it out with Real Madrid in career mode now for example I find a 35 year old AP from Croatia and one 31 year old AP from Germany along with a Belgian star keeper, a versatile Austrian defender etc. If there are small alterations of attributes or positions I might have missed that, but it doesn’t really give another game experience if it just shows what the game would look like with no real name licenses for players. I’d love to play an “alternate reality” career, but with the relative strength of the teams mostly preserved.