It's 110% from the database... you must not be a Merengues fan, so you probably wouldn't look to see the hard data for their players. First thing I always do is look at the players' CA/PAs just to see what the game thinks of my boys' futures and/or current careers. Just to prove to you I'm pretty certain you're in the wrong... take a peaky-peaks at ma boy Takuhiro Nakai. Definitely -9 as you have mentioned... but Peak PA is 247 when the max is only 200. Having not played FM22 and FM21, since I just played 20 until a year ago, Peak PA is something new to me. And Takuhiro Nakai has more than the max allowed. If you edit it, the computer beeps at you and tells you that's not allowed.