Jump to content

albertocerdeira.4

Members+
  • Posts

    91
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by albertocerdeira.4

  1. Very happy with this blog. If this is well implemented, It's the most exciting blog I've could read
  2. SI, please, we need an update about this issue. Think that there is a huge amount of data and feedback from the community, what was you were asking us for. Sorry for being insistent but there is a lot of people waiting to know if we have to give up with FM23 and wait for FM24. A sentence like "We don't think this is possible to solve for this year" would be enough, despite the disappointness it would be.
  3. Has SI in their plans to tell us something about this issue after another failed update?
  4. They have this issue reported since beginning of 2022 at least. There is any excuse
  5. Waiting for SI to tell us something. For me the only valid answer is "We'll do whatever is needed in order to have this issue fixed". But I am dreaming, I suppose
  6. Results of my comparison in youth development in biggest NT in FM vs reality comparing WC 2022 VS WC 2030 here: Still completely broken
  7. Add those data to the bug tracker, I just made a WC 2030 in FM vs WC 2022 reality to compare the newgens that arrive to the NT in FM. The results are depressing.
  8. As we are here to show data... I'm coming So, last week @Zachary Whytetold us that there would be changes, I told that to know if the issue is fixed it was as simple as simulate ten years and seeing how National Teams looks like... and I simulate until 2030 to see the biggest NT look like. Let's take a look into Spain 2 regens generated into the first NT, let's analyse the players that were in the Spain NT in World Cup 2022 that in 2014 they weren't in the game...: - Eric García - Alejandro Balde - Gavi - Dani Olmo - Ansu Fati - Yeremy Pino - Ferrán Torres - Nico Williams 8 new players vs 2 players So we can tell that FM has a 25% of the reality capacity to create new player able to play in the National Teams... but let's try with another team, Spain is a very young squad and can be better to try with another... for example, Brazil 4 new players... it's becoming better... let's analyse the players that were in the 2022 WC squad that in 2014 were 16 age old or less... - Vinicius - Rodrygo - Martinelli - Antony Ok with Brazil... there are improvements, what we can say... let's try with another as Brazil back up were much older than spanish ones. Argentina would be a good pick Argentina... 2 regens, let's compare with 2022 WC - Romero - Nehuén - Nahuel - Enzo - Almada - Exequiel - Julián Álvarez Another case as Spain... FM gives Argentina a 70% less percentage of creating NT players, 7 in reality vs 2 in FM Let's see France... this is gonna be fun ONE DAMN PLAYER, let's compare with the players generate France since 2014... - Koundé - Saliba - Konaté - Disasi - Tchouameni - Camavinga - Guendouzi - Mbappé - Kolo Muani 9 against 1!!!! Well done SI!!!! It's so realistic!!!!!! Let's try with Portugal... hope it will be better: 4 players... lets compare with WC 2022... - Diogo Costa - Antonio Silva - Dalot - Vitinha - Nunes - Leao - Joao Félix - Gonçalo Ramos 8 vs 4... amazing, we are improving, FM has the capability of generate the 50% of the newgens Portugal does... let's end with England... 3 players... let's compare with raw reality... - Ramsdale - Trent - Jude - Gallagher - Rice - Mount - Foden - Saka 8 vs 3 to end... let's summarize Spain: 8 vs 2 Brazil: 4 vs 4 Argentina: 7 vs 2 France: 9 vs 1 Portugal: 8 vs 4 England: 8 vs 4 Result: Reality 44 vs 19 for the reality, and I have to admit that the patch improves it significantly. To summarize, in this 6 teams, where the first and second division were loaded, the game can only replicate the 43,18 % of the newgens that reality can generate. Count this with all the teams and think how a save in 2032 could look like... completely broken. With the other countries is worse, for example if you go to Serbia and Croatia there is not newgens... Serbia and Croatia, of course I have to accept that in those countries there are no new wonderkids...of course SI The database I am using includes 13 countries and more than 20 playable leagues, so there's no excuse for this. It's a known issue since October 2022 and it's so easy to analyse like I just did, so no more excuses please. The youth development is broken as never before 2022. For my part, I won't put any euro in your account until I see data here that it is solved, but I know that it won't have any consequence. Would like to think that maybe if we do enough noise SI will fix it... but it seems impossible.
  9. Can you tell me how many players under 25 are in the Spanish, Brazilian, Argentinian, English and France squads in World Cup 2030? Can you tell me how many players under 25 have been playing in that squads in WC 2022? Because the difference is more than painful And my save have 15 leagues playable, so it's not a DB issue
  10. 3 players aged less than 20 in the biggest 19 teams match squads. Nothing more to report. I don't know if SI test something or this is intentional. How you can tell you are reviewing and improving this and came out with an update like this. Don't know how you can laugh at us at this way. Zaire Emery, Garnacho, Malo Gusto, Gavi, Álvaro Rodríguez, Camavinga, Rico Lewis, Bajcetic, Harvey Elliott, Musiala, Bynoe Gittens... Are impossible to generate by SI. It's a f* disgrace. I am speechless. 18 months. 18 MONTHS @Neil Brock explain me why for the game it's impossible to generate this. I'm waiting. 18 months with the long term viability of the saves completely broken. Tell me why.
  11. It was my previous data choice, now I have more than 15 playable leagues. In your saves there are a "Musiala" in the world cup in 2030?
  12. Completely new save +100.000 players loaded. Watching World Cup squads in 2030 is depressing.
  13. As i mentioned in the player development topic, some improvements but not enough at all Why the hell SI don't want Musialas, Bellinghams, Gavis, Rodrygos or Vinicius to break into the best teams with 18-20 years??? Why the hell in the World Cup 2030 there is no players aged less than 21-22? What the hell do you test before launching an update? I am completely disappointed with this years game, don't have words to describe how much it annoys me the youth development issue. WHAT EXCUSE DO YOU HAVE TO NOT FIX THIS IN 18 MONTHS, FOR GOD'S SAKE?
  14. Checked it out. Some improvements but soo far to be balanced, another time that looks like SI haven't tested deeply absolutely nothing. Squads in 2032 are older than in 2022 and the average regens are worse than the 2022 wonderkids. It's better than before but for me this is not enough. Don't know what the hell do you disbalance in 2022 but it's a long way to be fixed Seems impossible to SI to generates Pedri's, Gavi's, Bellingham's or Mbappés who breaks into the first teams with 18 years. Disgraceful and very disappointed. I'll try to share the data this evening but as you are noticing it continues to be unbalanced. Test the damn updates before launching, for the god's sake. I'm more disappointed than ever with a game I've been playing for +15 years
  15. Somebody to check?? I wont be able to do it until tomorrow
  16. What do we say to the God of Death? Waiting for the update as if it was the beta as I need youth development fixed
  17. We understand that, what we don't get it is why is this incompatible with seeing newgens overpassing 32 years old players. We don't want 10 Messis in the game, what we want and we asked for during a year it's about that the game can generate a england midfielder aged 20-22 that it is better than Mount, Henderson or Rice aged 32-36. And I didn't see it in four saves.
  18. The topic about this is where SI want to put their resources. If they have, for example, 500 hours of work and SI prefers to put hours into making a squad planner and making a Manager timeline instead of solve a known and, for a lot of people, crucial issue it's ok. It's their game and I'm free to put or not my money into it. But for me, something like this issue, that is as easy to see as simulate ten campaigns into the game and see the biggest national teams and the bigges clubs, is it not acceptable. SI releases this years game being COMPLETELY AWARE of this issue, a issue reported last year, an issue reported in the beta and an issue reported after the full release and it's almost March and the issue it's still there. If you have almost one year and a half and you didn't fix an issue making excuses as "we have to be careful, we can compromise long term stability" when the long term stability is already broken what they are doing is to make laugh of all of us and treating us like idiots. There is no excuse for a game to have a crucial issue for one year and a half without being solved.
  19. They don't make the mistake in programming that intentionally, but they dont do what is needed to fix the problem (put the work and the resources until you fix the issue) intentionally. SI simply prefers to put their resources into another areas. They have enough money and sales to not care about us. There is no possible excuse to not fix something you easily see at early stages after two betas and two full releases, with more or less 10 patches in the process. There isn't and there won't be. It's pure laziness and I can understand it as they make millions this way.
  20. FM's franchise is in their best moment of all time in terms of sales, so I can understand they don't really care about this. For me they have lost all the credit they had after having INTENTIONALLY broken one of their core features, because the problem is reported for a long long time. They have the money (our money) to put a bunch of resources into this and they didn't wanted to do it, so for me it's impossible to trust the franchise, Miles and Neil never more
  21. SI has decided to do the youth development like this... And that's all. More than a year with the issue being known and they didn't solve it, because they don't want and they don't care about the long term saves. If you have already paid for the game you are useless now. But wait for somebody to tell you that the game balance is ok when in 2034 70% of big teams have a medium age of 32-33
×
×
  • Create New...