Jump to content

The FM24 Youth Academy Challenge


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

I'm really tempted by England slog as a side quest, but I'm undecided between standard vanilla way of VNN/VNS or using a tier 10 database from another challenges topic (as I did in FM22) and pick last team from one of divisions. What do you think? Will the second option count for the YAC?

Link to post
Share on other sites

image.png.fef97439b3fcf3d1661f0a057aef75c5.png

 

RC Jaen Season 32/33

I was right about things starting to look up, as we continued the great run of form we ad in the previous two seasons into our first season of the Spanish Second Division. I would have been glad just to avoid relegation but we went well beyond what was expected.

2252570_20240914102834_1.thumb.png.bee9068d721311fcd575a03ceaf979a3.png

We had an absolutely unbelievable season and manged to get in to the play-off positions and we were only 4 games away from the big time. Unfortunately the boys fell short, but they have proven themselves to be more than ready for the challenge ahead. 

2252570_20240928130307_1.thumb.png.e670f89218973780b8817b4624cad457.png

The intake for the year looks reasonable, with Martin looking to have the potential to break through in a few seasons, unfortunately Budzynski's determination and personality will probably prevent him from ever fulfilling his potential.

2252570_20240912212241_1.thumb.png.521688b2357076079537f50687580440.png

Hopefully we have a few seasons consolidating in the Second division before making a push for La Liga. The challenge now looks like there is real potential it can be completed some day. We really could be doing with getting a 'superstar' through the academy though, as while there have been plenty solid intakes, no absolute standout as of yet.

Link to post
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, Ron_Swanson said:

I'm really tempted by England slog as a side quest, but I'm undecided between standard vanilla way of VNN/VNS or using a tier 10 database from another challenges topic (as I did in FM22) and pick last team from one of divisions. What do you think? Will the second option count for the YAC?

Why don’t you do the 10 tier but only have 9 playable that way you can play a team previously unplayable that come up from tier 10?

Would still have an asterisk next to the HoF entry if completed though as it’s not vanilla, which is where I’d be with my attempt in Scotland playing 1 level down from vanilla.

Link to post
Share on other sites

40 minutes ago, The_Gato_In_Goal said:

You can expand the praise players to over 7.75 or so as long as you have the motivation to do so. 99% of time I get no complaints, but once every few seasons I'll have a player complain when a praised him for like a 7.80.

Ya, I tend to do just above 8 for praise and below 6 for warning so it isn't as much "work".  If things are rolling I won't bother at all

Link to post
Share on other sites

56 minutes ago, mpm2342 said:

Ya, I tend to do just above 8 for praise and below 6 for warning so it isn't as much "work".  If things are rolling I won't bother at all

I praise above 8 but never thought to warn for below 6. Cheers! 

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, JD78 said:

I praise above 8 but never thought to warn for below 6. Cheers! 

As the club gets bigger reputation wise I start warning them under 6.50 and only praise over 9.00 as standards rise, but at the beginning of such a save under 6.00 and over 7.75 for me

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Brora Rangers - Season 4 - Cinch League 2 (Scotland)

Brora_Rangers_Logo.png.c6bb6cedd48baa4b8bd9a60f8991ed0c.png

 

Update: In the last season I finished one place out of the promotion playoff. This season I barely escaped the relegation playoff. I took it to the last game of the season, and was down 0-2 during halftime, but a goal in the 84th minute by a newly signed youth candidate  put me in 8th (out of 10). For the upcoming season I decided to go for a high-line, possession tactic. My old center back just retired, and now I replace him with a repurposed full back with great speed. I had a good crop in youth intake, so hopefully I can turn it around.

 

Screenshot2024-09-29at9_04_04PM.thumb.png.532678a19846acf050193dd1176a1d9d.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

Escudo_del_Deportivo_Quito.png

Sociedad Deportivo Quito - Youth Intake and Youth Review Season 6

Frustrating poor intake given the investment we've put into facilities and the last straw for our HOYD with more less than stellar personalities at the top. Will look to find a HOYD with maybe worse stats, but a Perfectionist or Model Citizen personality.

LqwFS6.jpg

 

Class of 2024

Alvarez 01a seems to have hit his PA and is a Good LigaPro Serie A player.
Castillo 01b didn't develop on loan for 2 seasons, will try to loan again and likely release him at the end of the season.
Batioja 01c - Released
Briones 01d seems to have hit his PA and is a Good LigaPro Serie A player.
Ayovi 01e kicked up a fuss about leaving early in the season, but got over himself and we locked him down to a long-term deal. Started to get bids from Spanish/Portuguese clubs, but we turned them down and convinced him that he's a leader in the locker room. He is a Star LigaPro Serie A player that may have some PA left, but probably is at his cap.
Mantilla 01f also kicked up a fuss, also got over it and I will offer him a new deal once the agent allows me to take the release clause out (he still has 3 years on the current one). He was convinced to spurn Porto after we told his he was a key locker room leader. He is also a Star LigaPro Serie A player who might have some more PA to develop into. Has made 2 caps for Ecuador now and scored 2 goals.

Class of 2025

Jimenez 02a is the backup keeper. I tend to ruin backup keeper careers and his is no different. He is a Leading Ascenso Nacional player with LigaPro Serie A potential he likely won't reach.
Garcia 02b developed well as a rotation option this season. He is now a Decent LigaPro Serie A player with room to grow.
Garcia 02c played so poorly in the first team that we had to loan him out to try to salvage his career. Hopefully he will develop from being a Leading Ascenso Nacional player to his LigaPro Serie A potential.
Macias 02d lost his starting role midway through the season (and his Professional personality), but continued to develop. Worried that he's stagnated at his PA cap, but no complaints if he's only a Good LigaPro Serie A player.

Class of 2026

Arce 03a developed a bit, but we are very deep at RWB so loaned him out for the coming season as he's turned 18. Is a Leading Ascenso Nacional player with LigaPro Serie A potential.
Loor 03b performed decent last season and developed a little so he will continue to be a rotation option as a Decent Liga Pro Serie A player.
Estupinan 03c didn't develop much, but performed well in his minutes so will continue to be our backup RWB despite being a Leading Ascenso Nacional player.
Valencia 03d has fallen behind and we are looking to give him a loan as he's 18 now. Is a Leading Ascenso Nacional player.
Carabali 03e started to develop last season, but didn't play well in his minutes. We loaned him out this season to the second tier (like most of the others). He is a Leading Ascenso Nacional player.
Mendez 03f deputized well for Ayovi 01e when he got hurt at the start of the season. Earned his backup spot and is a Decent LigaPro Serie B player.
Valarezo 03g came on strong in the second half and took a starting spot in the first team. Is up to a Decent LigaPro Serie A player and has a good personality and PA to fill.
Pineda 03h improved from 3* potential to 5* accoridng to my staff and has made the most of regular first team minutes. Nearly set the league record for shutouts this season and is now a Good LigaPro Serie A player

Class of 2027

(These guys hang out in the youth team and don't develop unless otherwise stated)

Russell 04a
Zambrano 04b earned a first team call up when Garcia 02c disappointed, but didn't get much playing time. Has a great personality and solid attributes, so once he begins to develop we could be forced to switch to a 2 man system up top.
Orellana 04c
Valencia 04d
Mina 04e
Mero 04f looks like he could be one to watch with his physical attributes.
Bolanos 04g
Zambrano 04h

Class of 2028

(These guys hang out in the youth team and don't develop unless otherwise stated)

Naula 05a
Valencia 05b
Castillo 05c
Vaca 05d
Mina 05e is developing well and may earn a call up this season
Saavedra 05f looks like he could be one to watch with his physical attributes.

Link to post
Share on other sites

bekescsaba-1912-elore-logo.png.11fca080bc6e702b2e89de93544ee822.png

Hungary - Season 2027/28

Second season in the top division and we finished 7th, 1 place above last season. This was a season of transition when lots of young players replaced some originals and developed over the season. I had a young GK that was showing as 2 star CA and I kept getting messages saying he was training very well so I threw him in the team along with the others. We weren't consistent but it did the young players the world of good. Unfortunately exited the Cup at the first hurdle. Barna27A fired in 20 goals in 31 games (spoiler if you click the link!). Not much more to say about this season.

Good looking winger, CB and WB in the youth intake that I'm pleased about.

 

Facilities stalling on upgrades however, they keep giving me coaching badges,

 

Season 2028/29

A very similar tale in the league, 7th place again. Made it to the 5th round of the cup and was dumped out by a team in the unplayable league. I was gutted! More youngsters in to the first team, progressing well. I really am enjoying watching players improve at a fairly decent rate after playing with a semi pro team for so long! Apologies that I don't have screenshots of intakes, previews etc. I will make sure I grab them from the 32/33 season. The screenshots of players you see now are their current levels, I'm a bit behind updating the thread hence the quickfire nature. Disaster in January as Barna27A decided he wanted to move to a bigger club. Despite us having some very good young players we weren't getting many strikers through at this point so it was a real shame. The other shame was that the board bent over and accepted PSG's pitiful £2.3m bid so I couldn't even sneak in any clauses. This will be a recurring theme in this save as you'll see over the next few posts I make. I'm keeping an eye on the 'stars' that have left us behind and since he left us Barna has scored lots of goals for PSG II but hasn't played for the first team yet. His value has dropped quite a bit. I wonder if he'll make the step up. He'd have scored a hundred goals for us by now. :(

 

Used the cash to upgrade training ground and junior set up. More coaching badges for me too. 

 

Useful looking WB and AMC in the youth intake.

Edited by JD78
Link to post
Share on other sites

Cipolletti 2028/29

 

Our first season in the top division. 7000-1 odds. Picked to finish last. Somehow went on a 15 match unbeaten run and finished 4th! I'll take it. We're in big financial trouble so I can't increase our youth network or training facilities, so we'll see what next season brings...

spacer.png

spacer.png

spacer.png

spacer.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi managers

I started reading this forum and really enjoy! I'm a long time FM player, but never started a youth academy save (until now )

Always build a very good scouting network and sign very good potetials etc, but now when i will skip FM25, i'm getting into this

I have a question

Guys, how do you decide which youth will be good for future?

I started in VNL South, and finally promoted in second season, but i got very useless youth intakes (slows, bad person etc)... and I'm already scared :)

I played non-league divisions before, but always signed/loans player that will help us, but i don't know... hmm, so my question :D  

Sry for my english

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, underbala said:

Hi managers

I started reading this forum and really enjoy! I'm a long time FM player, but never started a youth academy save (until now )

Always build a very good scouting network and sign very good potetials etc, but now when i will skip FM25, i'm getting into this

I have a question

Guys, how do you decide which youth will be good for future?

I started in VNL South, and finally promoted in second season, but i got very useless youth intakes (slows, bad person etc)... and I'm already scared :)

I played non-league divisions before, but always signed/loans player that will help us, but i don't know... hmm, so my question :D  

Sry for my english

What team are you managing and are they professional status or semi-pro?

Link to post
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, underbala said:

Hi managers

I started reading this forum and really enjoy! I'm a long time FM player, but never started a youth academy save (until now )

Always build a very good scouting network and sign very good potetials etc, but now when i will skip FM25, i'm getting into this

I have a question

Guys, how do you decide which youth will be good for future?

I started in VNL South, and finally promoted in second season, but i got very useless youth intakes (slows, bad person etc)... and I'm already scared :)

I played non-league divisions before, but always signed/loans player that will help us, but i don't know... hmm, so my question :D  

Sry for my english

Well, that's the challenge! :D

I tend to try to initially trust my assistant on their potential, but I also have a spreadsheet to look at their attributes and see how well they fit any role I might want them in. So based on those things, I try to use the most talented one, as well as retrain those who are better fitted to other positions.

Some people are very flexible with tactics, and chance based on the players they get through intakes, I'm personally more of a retrainer to fit my tactic of choice. If you have gotten promoted from the Vanarama South you are doing something right, so just do the same you are and hope for good intakes, and try to improve the youth coaching and youth recruitment whenever you can to get better intakes. Facilities can come later.

Also, your English is easily readable, so don't worry about it. English isn't my native language either, just keep using it and it will flow more natural as you do.

Link to post
Share on other sites

@Padders totally understand about the write up, you've done so many seasons and this endless yoyoing between Championship and Premier League with the intakes not really giving you much to work with must be so frustrating. Again I salute your perseverance with this challenge.

I wonder if Harrogate are just cursed, if you started over with Dulwich or Macclesfield if you'd already have wrapped the challenge up 100+ seasons ago.

I think I can safely speak for all on here that we are rooting for you to succeed!

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, underbala said:

Weymouth, semi-pro, negative balance

That's going to be tough! What I would suggest is that you establish who your best young players are and just play them every game possible and be satisfied with treading water for a few seasons. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

F.K._Raa.png.d4a9df0c1d2a4bad563060438666fafc.png

FK Rača Bratislava
Season review
Season 14 | 2037-2038
Niké liga

Transfers | Affiliates | Facilities | Finances | Manager Profile | Club overview

 

Another year, another league win! For the 5th consecutive time we won the Slovakian league. Unfortunately we were not able to win the Cup again; for the first time in 5 years time we didn't win the Cup. We lost in the Third Round against MSK Zilina. In the first couple of rounds I play with a lot of youth/back-up players. And normally they are good enough to deliver, but this time not.

4WPI1VL.png
eXUbr3z.png
5tWHxmL.png
VI0v1rc.png
PySkZs7.png

 

In the Champions League Playoffs we met FC Sion again, the same team as last season. And this time we won both matches against them: 4-1 and 3-1. So we qualified for the CL League Phase! We gained 7 points, which was just not enough to qualify for the next round. We only won 1 game, and drew 4 times. The best result was 0-0 against Man City. Overall I'm quite happy with how we played, and with a bit more luck we could have qualified for the next round. Let's hope we can do that next season.
DsLfwBu.png
kvgSW5r.png

In the NXGN 2038 Wonderkids list we had 2 players: Richard Nagy 35b and Igor Augustini 36c.
PSW86UE.png

Youth intake
The preview was mwah, although it was labelled as 'excellent'. But the actual intake gave us 3 Elite Talents. Tomislav Čabraja 38b already played 5 matches and scored 2 goals, so that's really promising.
tOnQRNx.png
OSErW9t.png
KNHDRLa.png

Spoiler

1QlGxqm.pngCvwvqje.png4xKE9Bx.png

Progress
sklwian.png

0LtfgDH.png

Nmwmd3z.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

bekescsaba-1912-elore-logo.png.15c5131c513fdd48b1f2e7b9270b7785.png

The Hungary adventure continues. I'm going to use this post to do a quick review of the seasons that I just played through and I'll do a more comprehensive season by season update from here on in.

 

2029/30

We finished 8th in the league which was a place lower than the last 2 seasons but I never felt we were in trouble. We got to the final of the cup but sadly lost out 3-1 aet to the Hungarian giants Ferencvaros. Another season of growth for the young players. The GK that I put in the team is getting better but is raw. We have a young defence and we ship quite a few goals. At the start of the season we lost our best defender and player Laszlo 26A to AC Milan. for just £1.1M and a sell on clause. Used the cash to improve facilities.

 

We got our best youth intake yet with 8 players who I felt had real potential. 

 

2030/31

A very good second half of the season in the league saw us finish 4th which is the final European place to qualify for the Conference League although I was sweating on that a bit. That European place goes to the Cup winner so I was praying that Champions Ferencvaros would do me a favour and win the Cup which they did comfortably. Phew. Europe next season! We got knocked out of the Cup at the first hurdle which was disappointing after last year's run to the final. I wasn't even using a rotated squad, just a crap performance against a team from the league below. 

 

Yet again, AC Milan swooped in and took our best player Valkovszki 27B for £3.1m plus 35% sell on clause. We also got money for appearances and first international cap. Used the cash to upgrade facilities however I had to 'leak to press' to get that to sanction the training facilities upgrade even though we had plenty of money. 

 

Youth intake wasn't as good as last year. An AMC and a STR book look good though.

 

2031/32

European football! Our first foray into Europe saw us draw Dundee which I thought was tricky but winnable, The first leg was at home and we were 2 nil down before the Conference League music had stopped playing! :D Great! We did rally to 2-2 but then they scored a late winner. All to do in the second leg and we were doing it too. We went 1 down then euqlised on the night right on 45 mins. Then took the lead on 45+1 and extended it at 45+3 minutes. Crazy end to the first half. We scored again on 61 minutes to make it 6-4 to us on aggregate. 2 minutes later we had a player sent off and that was that. they scored 3 goals to win 7-6 over the 2 legs. I don't know about anyone else but I find it really tough to not concede when down to 10 men on this version of FM. It seems almost inevitable. Any tips welcome. 

 

Another good season in the league saw us finish 3rd but nowhere near challenging for the top. We got to the final of the Cup but were comfortably beaten 3-1 by Ferencvaros again. 

AC Milan AGAIN came in for my best player at the start of the season. This is becoming a dreadful habit. We got £5m plus 35% sell on for Kis 28A.

 

Youth Intake was pretty good with a RB and a STR looking like the best prospects.

Link to post
Share on other sites

On 01/10/2024 at 19:06, Neo_Geo said:

Why don’t you do the 10 tier but only have 9 playable that way you can play a team previously unplayable that come up from tier 10?

Would still have an asterisk next to the HoF entry if completed though as it’s not vanilla, which is where I’d be with my attempt in Scotland playing 1 level down from vanilla.

I thought about it but would be more fun to get some of the worst possible teams. Maybe I'll do it off the forum to see if it's worth the effort

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Ron_Swanson said:

I thought about it but would be more fun to get some of the worst possible teams. Maybe I'll do it off the forum to see if it's worth the effort

Getting a team you like is half the battle with this challenge (that’s why I took a scotland D10 pack, went to 5th tier as playable and simulated for 30 seasons to get the team I wanted!)

Good luck finding one

Link to post
Share on other sites

Crewe United 2042 Season Update

Screenshot2024-07-30134224.png.ef182920480cb234aa65837ca9339839.png

Season 18 Update:

A great season that was fun as it was long. The squad had 64 matches with 38 league matches and then Europa Conference and cups. I rotated 2 squads with the first squad getting about 40 games and the second the rest. I might include a 3rd squad for the easier cup matches to take a few games off the schedule for the top squad.  That makes a lot of Wed / Sat match weeks where the squads just alternate.

We did amazing in the league coming in 2nd and qualifying for the Europa League. We also made it to the Europa Conference League league phase in spectacular fashion with a shocking 5-0 away win over Shakhtar in a matchup I fully expected to lose. We then managed to do great in the league phase and moved on to a favourable knock out phase draw. The run ended against Fenerbahce who are way too strong for us.  Made some good £ on that run and got some facilities upgrades from it.

Screenshot2024-10-03150848.png.cb76e18ea850772607b7062daa3bc967.png
Screenshot2024-10-04103745.thumb.png.aa2e115da7a844b1d37500740199de6a.png

Screenshot2024-10-04144444.png.0db7b132cf56a15825d6f3c7aa6caf30.png
Screenshot2024-10-04144501.png.e564676ebfb013358e3403792973b5d9.png

Transfers:

Spoiler

Screenshot2024-10-04143623.png.30c7df36be92de45d4115a22d306c16c.png

Youth Candidates:

The streak is still alive, though the relative talent level is decreasing as our squad gets better.  Beckett will get some rotation time on the senior squad as he is a very good. fast winger with 15 pace and 16 acceleration.

Screenshot2024-10-03110414.thumb.png.68f5b53d6f82c54d07520e97efcbcccb.png
Screenshot2024-10-03110428.thumb.png.dbdcfdf837c5a2c5e61932f2008f89e8.png

Personalities could be better for sure.

Screenshot2024-10-04145602.png.5deb06d243651c29b9098e4b822a7514.png

Screenshot2024-10-04145757.png.8c0d91064a3aa229f279be6f18726bb2.pngScreenshot2024-10-04145823.png.149725cf5db58358e9c52da9c32265e1.png
Screenshot2024-10-04145845.png.fcecab2889f3ddf860fc7ac2414ae724.png

Squad Update:

Here is how the squad is rated heading into next season. Overall some fantastic improvement at ST, RW and CD. Though we have a looming issue with Graham and McKinney as they were not happy at all when I exercised their contract extensions ... hopefully they can cry in the corner for a while and get over it. It would hurt to lose them as there is a fair drop off to the next man up.

Screenshot2024-10-04104746.png.33f73ddbe340fe856f155c86cd917ff1.png

The squad rating jumper 2 points over the season, putting us almost at the Premiership target. As long as I can hold the team together, we should be getting very close to challenging Linfield for 1st place.

Screenshot2024-10-04150152.png.7ec36743185a5249ffaff813ec306d9e.pngScreenshot2024-10-04150202.png.fcfaa528f63a347bea2798ed4de84cc7.png

Bingo

Got a few more squares ... a quarter of the way there.

Screenshot2024-10-04150627.png.780b1c488f67570c08f3719e2350eb45.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...