All the teams in that league are half a star, that's not an accurate way to gauge rep.
Basically, reputation is a number from 1-10000. Until we get the pre-game editor, we can't see the reputations. However, Hashtag will be low. The team I usually aim for has a reputation of around 1800 and that usually takes about 20 attempts. Honestly, for Hashtag, you're looking at 1/1000 chance, maybe lower. The higher reputation clubs are heavily favoured (there are one's you'll almost always see).