Jump to content

FM 25 DEVELOPMENT UPDATE


Recommended Posts

23 minutes ago, DP said:

So, no ‘introduction to women’s football’ today then and the roadmap has been officially scrapped?

It was confirmed in the statement from SI yesterday that first roadmap feature reveal has now moved to January.

Edited by Domoboy23
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 4.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Just now, tezcatlipoca665 said:

Can somebody provide evidence that the inclusion of women's football is the reason for the delay of this release? There are many confident assertions that's the case here, so there must be an official statement or something.

There is no official statement, and I'm pretty sure there never will be one, but the consequence of that is people speculating and arguing over what happened.

Link to post
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, tezcatlipoca665 said:

Can somebody provide evidence that the inclusion of women's football is the reason for the delay of this release? There are many confident assertions that's the case here, so there must be an official statement or something.

There are also just as many confident assertions that it isn’t. People are picking their side and sticking to it, as usual with tribal internet arguments. 

The fact is we don’t actually know but it’s not out of the question that an aggregation of things has led to the delay, including the introduction of women’s football. 

Edited by DP
Link to post
Share on other sites

Surely the addition of the women's game being added wont have had much effect on the game getting delayed. 

Will that not just be the equivalent of adding new leagues to the game like they have done for many years.

Obvs additional motion capture etc will be needed but I would have thought with the new engine that would be being done in advance anyway.

As always I am not a game developer so I am just speculating.

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, CamAshworth said:

Surely the addition of the women's game being added wont have had much effect on the game getting delayed. 

Will that not just be the equivalent of adding new leagues to the game like they have done for many years.

Obvs additional motion capture etc will be needed but I would have thought with the new engine that would be being done in advance anyway.

As always I am not a game developer so I am just speculating.

Until we get to see the features for women’s football we won’t really be able to draw any kind of conclusions. In its simplest form, yeah, you’re probably right, but there could be a need for a separate ME, the financial models are different, the economics are different. At this point, who knows what it’s gonna look like, how much work has gone in, and how much resource that’s required

Link to post
Share on other sites

People, a complete cancellation of FM25 is not realistic, nor should it be advocated. We're all a bit angry and disappointed, but the sale of the game keeps jobs and helps its further development. And yes, I will buy it. I believe it's important to support the team that has worked hard and continues to do so.

Link to post
Share on other sites

For the financials looking poor, they should have branched out 20+ years ago and had a whole franchise of sports management sims.

FM was a great template to plug in other attributes. Other sports were ripe for plucking, cricket, baseball, F1 have all had successful management games. Money on the table there.

Also, they spent way too long refusing to make the game "current" gen. They left an entire generation of gamers on the table. Not to mention console owners.

I cant really think of an innovation worthy move in 10 years or so? It all feels so stagnant. Which is why this version was so important. But honestly, they've needed an upgrade for years and refused to. Leading to this.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, DavutOzkan said:

They should also use this delay to come up with a better looking logo. 

I do not think it is going to be changed for a while, as they've already invested in it. An example is given below from Brighton's dugout:

 image.thumb.jpeg.877127be98caa93224ce8de8e222828c.jpeg

Link to post
Share on other sites

16 минут назад, SlobaFMB сказал:

People, a complete cancellation of FM25 is not realistic, nor should it be advocated. We're all a bit angry and disappointed, but the sale of the game keeps jobs and helps its further development. And yes, I will buy it. I believe it's important to support the team that has worked hard and continues to do so.

Everyone decides for themselves, of course. Personally, I lost the desire to advanced support a couple of years ago. In addition, SI has Sega, which can support its asset. Or sell it to a more ambitious and large publisher, if desired.

Miles himself has said many times that they are not an independent studio, but a property of Sega.

I didn't collect this posts, but it's easy to search by keyword 'sega' in X

Link to post
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, davehanson said:

Again, they are really bad points you make. If they introduce sim-like features and a stadium creator and it caused a 4 months delay - there would be the same reaction as now. Why? Because only a very small % of people would want those things. 

And you are right - Unity will be the biggest and probably only factor here that has caused this delay, But your points don't help your argument.

interesting that you cannot see how people will feel the game is out of date after a few months of playing it, but can see this. Very, very interesting

Link to post
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, silentwars said:

Would you and others have requested it if you knew the chaos it would cause though? I suspect not. 

I don't think anyone's got an issue with the women's game been introduced, but they should only announce it when they have the capablity to put it into the game without causing this disruption. 

loads of people have a problem with it. This forum is full of it

Link to post
Share on other sites

21 hours ago, ajw10 said:

do you think if they cancel FM25 then there will be an FM26?

Yes, why not? Surly Sega can fund SI for a year, they regularly say FM sells very well so they must have some credit?

With some foresight knowing that this was going to be tricky development year they could've sold a ME upgrade and Database for £10/15. I know this is never going to happen now but surly these were options.

And now the whole development/release schedule is forever out of sync, they aren't going to release FM26 in Oct/Nov 25 - FM25 should of been skipped. Anyway I never liked the Oct/Nov release, I think a release in sync with the start of the football season would be better.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, AllyJoseph said:

For the financials looking poor, they should have branched out 20+ years ago and had a whole franchise of sports management sims.

FM was a great template to plug in other attributes. Other sports were ripe for plucking, cricket, baseball, F1 have all had successful management games. Money on the table there.

Also, they spent way too long refusing to make the game "current" gen. They left an entire generation of gamers on the table. Not to mention console owners.

I cant really think of an innovation worthy move in 10 years or so? It all feels so stagnant. Which is why this version was so important. But honestly, they've needed an upgrade for years and refused to. Leading to this.

As I recall they did branch out. Think it was ice hockey and it didn't work. Cost them a fair bit of cash.

Link to post
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, ds_61_1 said:

There seems to be a heavy push from some posters in this thread to label any criticism aimed at the game as being due to a perceived backlash against women's football being included. This is very disingenuous, and it is starting to come off as trying to bait people into arguments.

That's exactly what 20% are here for, 50% don't post at all, 20% come for info and another 10% for some kind of sensible discussion on matters they care enough about. I suggested a while ago this thread should be locked till March, that's wasn't a joke, the mods are doing reasonable well to keep up ( I drop in and out reading a few posts only) with it but one baiting post can spawn 100s of replies. I've not been here that long but I've seen plenty of losers I would kick off in a instant because they bring nothing here, they just take and annoy.

Link to post
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, XaW said:

...

There's no doubt misogyny is playing a large part in this.

However I feel like you're glossing over things. It HAS to have had an impact. You say there's a dedicate team handling it so there can't be an impact - but you can assign that team to work on another feature. So there IS an opportunity cost here whether anyone likes it or not.

And I should point out it goes both ways too. SI didn't have to make the Unity upgrade come in this version. FM25 could have been the standard game with Womans football as the headline feature. 

There's a saying in software development - 'Stop starting, and start finishing'. It's a classic problem in software teams where we all bounce around and want to do absolutely everything. But the product suffers for that. You need to be focused on one big thing at a time. You finish that before you start another headline feature. 

I actually think this has been SI's main problem for years. And it is finally come home to roost now.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Disappointing news, but as someone in software development who's had my fair share of delays brought about by migrating to new tech and the ramifications that brings about sometimes I empathise. 

Next month marks the delivery of a project to replace our old tech with something more modern to one of our clients. We were supposed to deliver it in June. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just now, Delicate Dave said:

That's exactly what 20% are here for, 50% don't post at all, 20% come for info and another 10% for some kind of sensible discussion on matters they care enough about. I suggested a while ago this thread should be locked till March, that's wasn't a joke, the mods are doing reasonable well to keep up ( I drop in and out reading a few posts only) with it but one baiting post can spawn 100s of replies. I've not been here that long but I've seen plenty of losers I would kick off in a instant because they bring nothing here, they just take and annoy.

I quite agree. It should be locked. I'm not quite sure why @XaW felt it necessary to direct their anger at me. I've said nothing for nor against the inclusion of Women's football. It is neither here nor there for me. My post was a casual observation of what I was seeing. If the mods are removing misogynistic posts at the rate they are claiming thats great. However it then leaves a multitude of posts saying "everyone is saying its because of Women's football" which we clearly can't see.

Link to post
Share on other sites

After all of this, read the statement and hold and behold a word I rarely see SI use.

SORRY

Was that too hard to say? Now for my dream to be complete it needed to be written at the bottom signed Miles.

:D

Kidding aside. I hope SI do deliver us the game promise in March (maybe with some of the removed features in it, but I doubt it, those definitely will be on hold to be selling points for FM26), and do proper announcement with gameplay. I would even suggest making some Dev diaries like they are doing for Planet Coaster 2 and Civilization 7.

You don't need something big. A good camera and set microphones, some okay lightning and get two devs to play the game and show us the game. What has been added, how to do stuff, what gains do we have. Do a 20-minute video of that for each key feature of FM25. You have already a roadmap, do that.

Even if a bug shows up in the video, that is okay in my book, it only shows how difficult this whole process was/is.

Hype the game back up. But keep it honest if the game isn't perfect, say so. Be honest about it. Customers are going to love you for it.

The first thing to do (if it is legally possible), is to have Miles, do a video (no text, as it feels too impersonal, and have several open onions around him, so he can cry a little or at least have watery eyes :D ), telling people how sorry for this delay and then remove the onions and with a huge smile, announce a new release a database for FM24 with the last summer transfers (for free or paid, don't care which). Then build from there.

But do NOT, do what you did in the last couple of months, especially releasing the pre-orders, without any gameplay footage (those screenshots are screenshots, they look like mockups). Shows us some meat, show us this game exists and it is not a myth.

No text. Video. I prefer to see Miles (despite not liking him) or anyone else and talk about the features. Even if you don't do a gameplay showcase, do a 10-minute video. Doesn't need to be on a football pitch. Do it in-house, Do it in Miles's office. Do it in the studio.

Edited by grade
Link to post
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, paddypower said:

There's no doubt misogyny is playing a large part in this.

However I feel like you're glossing over things. It HAS to have had an impact. You say there's a dedicate team handling it so there can't be an impact - but you can assign that team to work on another feature. So there IS an opportunity cost here whether anyone likes it or not.

And I should point out it goes both ways too. SI didn't have to make the Unity upgrade come in this version. FM25 could have been the standard game with Womans football as the headline feature. 

There's a saying in software development - 'Stop starting, and start finishing'. It's a classic problem in software teams where we all bounce around and want to do absolutely everything. But the product suffers for that. You need to be focused on one big thing at a time. You finish that before you start another headline feature. 

I actually think this has been SI's main problem for years. And it is finally come home to roost now.

Agile teams and specialities though ain't it?

The women's team aren't necessarily gonna be able to help with the UI team or something like that, they might not have any Unity experience or experience in middleware in general. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, paddypower said:

There's no doubt misogyny is playing a large part in this.

However I feel like you're glossing over things. It HAS to have had an impact. You say there's a dedicate team handling it so there can't be an impact - but you can assign that team to work on another feature. So there IS an opportunity cost here whether anyone likes it or not.

And I should point out it goes both ways too. SI didn't have to make the Unity upgrade come in this version. FM25 could have been the standard game with Womans football as the headline feature. 

There's a saying in software development - 'Stop starting, and start finishing'. It's a classic problem in software teams where we all bounce around and want to do absolutely everything. But the product suffers for that. You need to be focused on one big thing at a time. You finish that before you start another headline feature. 

I actually think this has been SI's main problem for years. And it is finally come home to roost now.

Of course, people should and could be critical to this, but it's where the anger is directed that I have problem with.

1 minute ago, ds_61_1 said:

I quite agree. It should be locked. I'm not quite sure why @XaW felt it necessary to direct their anger at me. I've said nothing for nor against the inclusion of Women's football. It is neither here nor there for me. My post was a casual observation of what I was seeing. If the mods are removing misogynistic posts at the rate they are claiming thats great. However it then leaves a multitude of posts saying "everyone is saying its because of Women's football" which we clearly can't see.

No anger in my post, if if came across as such, then I'm sorry, tone can be hard to get through in writing only. It was more an attempt at explaining why it saddens me to see the misdirected criticism. And to be clear, only the first paragraph was directed to you alone, the rest was a general explanation as to why people react to others trying to blame women's football for what has happened.

And yes, there have been many direct posts pointing to it, and many have been removed due to unfiltered misogyny, but if you go back through the last 10 pages or so, I'm sure you will find plenty of examples mentioning women's football as the reason still.

Link to post
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, ds_61_1 said:

I quite agree. It should be locked. I'm not quite sure why @XaW felt it necessary to direct their anger at me. I've said nothing for nor against the inclusion of Women's football. It is neither here nor there for me. My post was a casual observation of what I was seeing. If the mods are removing misogynistic posts at the rate they are claiming thats great. However it then leaves a multitude of posts saying "everyone is saying its because of Women's football" which we clearly can't see.

I wouldn't call it misogyny, I think labels are easy to use when all we are seeing is a lack of education in a era when some men find it hard to distinguish between an "influencer's" comment for  monetary gain and their own reasoned thought process. They seem to simply parrot things out thinking most agree & it'll be popular. News folks it's not. Think for yourself, have you own reasons and be will to argue your corner accepting others might have ideas you can learn from and become a better you not a fake someone else.

Edited by Delicate Dave
Clarity
Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, ajw10 said:

interesting that you cannot see how people will feel the game is out of date after a few months of playing it, but can see this. Very, very interesting

Again, the game is out of date the moment you press continue - can you not see that?

But, if you want to get 'real life' with it the game is out of date usually 6 months after release. This version will be out of date 2 months after release - I can see the point. But, you know what - those that are worried about that sort of thing will do as they always have done - download an unofficial update that is provided by the wonderful modding community - free of charge. So what have 'you' lost out on?

 

And, if you want to make a point don't be sarcastic with it - just come out and say something. I'm not sure what exactly you find interesting, but just spell it out. 

Edited by davehanson
Link to post
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, DavutOzkan said:

They should also use this delay to come up with a better looking logo. 

Maybe they will as this one is now intrinsically linked with delays and bad press. I suggest replacing it with the laughing emoji.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, HighFlyingDwarf said:

I think Women's Football should be in the game but I definitely think it should have been put off another year based on the evidence so far.

Completely agree they should defo add womans football but should of got the core game right first put all there manpower and resources into that first.that team could of been put on the main game instead 

Edited by Weasek
Link to post
Share on other sites

Just a reminder that it's understandable that people will be upset etc, but personal attacks and attacking devs isn't on. Have had to remove a couple of really unnecessary comments.

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, paddypower said:

There's no doubt misogyny is playing a large part in this.

However I feel like you're glossing over things. It HAS to have had an impact. You say there's a dedicate team handling it so there can't be an impact - but you can assign that team to work on another feature. So there IS an opportunity cost here whether anyone likes it or not.

And I should point out it goes both ways too. SI didn't have to make the Unity upgrade come in this version. FM25 could have been the standard game with Womans football as the headline feature. 

 

The largest part of that new team is researchers, exactly the same as for the men's game. So no, you can't really pull resource from there to help you work on other features. SI have also expanded massively over the last decade in all areas of the company, so I just never understand when people say Women's Football has diverted resources and caused the delay.

On your second point, I agree, both didn't have to be the same year. A more ideal scenario now would have been FM25 launching on the same codebase as FM24 but with the addition of Women's Football, FM26 then being the Unity game. But it's clear that they have miscalculated how complicated the switch to Unity would be, so here we are.

Everyone is shouting "Cancel FM25 and focus on FM26!" As many have outlined, that is simply not possible for SEGA/SI, but a good question will be whether FM26 can possibly launch in their usual release window. Surely not?

Edited by TownForThePrem!
Link to post
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, tezcatlipoca665 said:

Can somebody provide evidence that the inclusion of women's football is the reason for the delay of this release? There are many confident assertions that's the case here, so there must be an official statement or something.

I'm sure there are lots of reasons, but they have obviously struggled with the Unity move, and they hired a whole team to work on women's football. I know hindsight is 20/20, but that feels like a bad allocation of resources given what's happened. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Exactly unless they are all working for free it's resources that could of been invested in the main game to get that ready to go before adding womans football.hired more people to do that  or just use the resources to do that.i don't see how it couldn't of not impacted the game in somehow that's just ridiculous.

Link to post
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, BJG123 said:

But if you chose to allocate funding to ensuring a smooth transition to Unity ahead of women's football, you wouldn't hire the same people. 

 

I run large software product teams, if I hire a bunch of data scientists to improve our machine learning capabilities at the expense of cloud architects and our fundamental infrastructure falls over as a result, that's on me and I made a bad decision to focus on something new ahead of fixing fundamentals. It's not that I put the data scientists on the wrong project, its that I messed up allocating budgets. 

If you think SI didn't hire people either with knowledge of Unity or specifically people to help with the Unity transition, in favour of hiring a team to build a women's database, then I have a bridge to sell you. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

On 10/10/2024 at 17:55, jimbo22 said:

Pretty ****** way to look at things. Because you dont find it interesting doesnt mean its not. You likely watch a ton of stuff people couldnt be arsed with. 

Found benjis secret account 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Miles himself said it will cost millions to add it to the game(womans football) in the blog about it years ago.and minimal return so I just don't understand why spend all that money until the main game is sorted.thats alot of money for s.i.like I said  I have absolutely no problem with it being added I think it should be but in time.i am just annoyed as was looking forward to getting my hands on fm 25

Edited by Weasek
Link to post
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, SkyNoudyo said:

It surprises me the inclusion of women’s football is such a large talking point. As if that’s what is causing the delay and not having to create an entirely new user interface using a completely new engine.

 

Because SI themselves complained about how difficult it was to add women's football prior to FM 24 and blamed it on the poor support we got and unfixed bugs.

 

Is there hope of keeping international football after the delay because they also said they'll need more time to get it right?

Edited by qwerty22
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...