Platinum

The vast majority of people only have one league set to full detail so I dont think that really matters. But yes the more people that show their results the better. Ill post my results today

Yep which is why its not worth the effort. I dont think the news items and match reports are repetitive or important enough to warrant having a rewriting

The reduction in injuries is worrying tbh. Really really want SI to make realistic injury rates possible in the next FM. I know that the injury rate was probably above their wanted threshold, however that threshold is already too low for people that want a more realistic injury rate.

Nah you wouldnt do this, instead you input the existing match report and get it to rewrite it, possibly with different tones or emphasises. It's good at summarising or rewriting text so I dont think it would often make up things that arent in the existing report.

Finances aside, changing to a subscription model would completely change their development cycle. The whole business model is built around getting new features out for an November release. If they didnt have the pressure of a strict November release every year then they could be more flexible with what they spend development time on and when. Who knows how it would impact things if it was actually implemented but it's wrong to say it would make no difference and there are potential benefits if you just look at it from a development point of view.

I know its just an example but I dont think using it to get info about a city is that useful - thats something I would look at, at most once maybe twice in my whole playing time and would have no impact on my enjoyment of the game. Also I dont see what difference there would be between the actual Wiki article and a rewriting of the wiki article by ChatGPT or some other LLM. I dont think my point had anything to do with ambition, its about making the right investments to improve the game, and I dont see how ChatGPT could improve the game without significant investment into making it an interface between user input and the game mechanics - however doing that is very time and cost intensive and I think quicker and immediately more effective workarounds are a better call. For example the current player interaction system is not great because 1) Players make complaints that dont make sense within the context of the game and 2) the answers you can give back to the player do not include sensible responses. ChatGPT wouldn't be able to solve those 2 problems unfortunately. All it could do is rephrase the complaint the player gives you. (I actually think ChatGPT would make things worse if was used to rephrase complaints but I wont go in to that here) Because of this I said that I think its only use would be to rewrite news articles - but I dont think this is worthy of the time or effort either. Some day in the future I hope LLMs can be used to enhance player interaction - but I dont think that time is now. But who knows maybe Im proven wrong.

Its not deliberate, it's a known issue

Mostly agree which is why I dont think its worth the effort (I dont think buggy is a given). I think simple things like news reports and can be rewritten using LLMs though to get rid of the repetitiveness. Would have to do some testing to see how often the rewriting loses the original meaning though. You could do the same for player interactions and press conferences however I think we actually want the interactions to be repetitive in this case and instead want our range of responses to be adequate - which is completely separate to any type of ChatGPYT technology. Ultimately though I would guess that the cost likely wouldnt make sense. If it uses an API from OpenAI for example it would be expensive and require the internet or require the user to run it locally on their machine which may or may not alter the system requirements in a significant way. Regardless I hope they are putting A LOT of resources in to improving interactions and immersion.

You can use LLMs as an interface though

Can you share a screenshot of your Staff Responsibilities Screen under the Transfers section

You can change it in the Staff Responsibilities screen

Yeah it is an issue, hopefully it's fixed in the winter update

Nah the ME is the same sine December, but yeah watching full matches does make a difference in terms of your understanding of how the game is panning out

I've had the goalkeeper handball it outside the area a couple times and I'm pretty sure he got a yellow. Seemed more like a glitch that's handled by giving a foul rather than a feature tbh

Thanks for all the help you give with the PCs, I'll give my support to this before the end of the month

And thanks for stepping in and posting that message. As you know we all want FM to be the best it can and hopefully the feedback in this thread helps the people at SI to notice some of the ways they haven't got it quite right and can improve. The only reason we care so much is because you've been able to make a game that we've come to love. Looking forward to what should be more transparent decision making - particularly when its about longstanding feature requests and bugs.

Great post, and its the same with me, most of my game time has been testing long term saves, which unfortunately aren't viable.

It really is a shame but I feel exactly the same way. Also if anyone has seen Rashidis recent video about FM where he offers constructive criticism I really agree there too. The one big flaw that encompasses nearly all the flaws: SI add new features to the game that have multiple bugs and don't get round to fixing them as they are deemed low priority. This happens every year and it means that you end up with a game with a growing amount of bugs that are never fixed. One simple example: the stats in the game are inconsistent and its been like this since at least FM17, thats 6 years. Please SI communicate with us better so that we understand why this happens. We honestly want to understand why features like earrings are added to the game (and are buggy and we can't even see during gameplay), while we have bugs to interactions, promises, stats, and more that aren't fixed. We love what this game has been and can be, but we can see flaws that are getting worse year on year, and it's making a significant part of your core fanbase unhappy. I understand that the reason is likely a commercial one, you have to grow your profits each year and adding features is seen as the way to grow profits, but the current trajectory of the game does not seem sustainable. Make the foundations solid and build on top of it. For me personally, if FM24 doesnt have a better set piece creator, the stats inconsistencies arent fixed or the DoF functionality isnt improved it will be very hard to justify spending money on it.

Great seeing this topic is still getting lots of talk and updates. I've actually become a bit disheartened due to the way the DoF operates in the game

Once you open the menu do you have to open the 'Custom views' section of the menu first? Or do they appear with the standard in-game views? If they do do you mind saying how you did this please?

I disagree with this, it takes multiple clicks and moving around of the mouse to change view, which is time consuming. Custom views shouldn't be under a separate menu item to other views and there should be a shortcut to change views.

Ah thats a shame! Thanks for letting me know though, do you know any other good place to put stats on a players profile on the base skin?

Similar question to the above, I have replaced existing stats with new ones on the Player->Reports->Stats page. I have added "Progressive Passes" and "High Intensity Sprints". However both values appear as -1, initially I thought it was due to the formatting being wrong but that isn't the reason I don't believe. Can anyone spot what I'm doing wrong here?

Ohh ok, thanks!

Sorry I meant to change the stats for different stats how would we go about doing that as there are no IDs which indicate which stat each row is for