I have been setting half a gray star for current ability and 3 stars for potential ability (just transfers), no matter a country or a competition, and specify a scout and an analyst. During the season the results come "in progress", it seems most of recommendations are displayed at the end of the season. Not sure if there is some bug or if it us, users, that are missing something here. Maybe someone (Moderators ?) could create some topic to clarify things, it would be helpful avoiding new topics about a potential bug when it might be nothing at all.